Thinking of consolidating, is this a fair trade in offer for my current watches?

[codecow]

Not sure about values but don’t settle. If you worked with a TS on this they can get you the piece you want.

[puma1552]

As someone else mentioned, I would definitely see if you can cash in the $37.5k today and then just go without while you wait for the DD of your choice to come in at the AD.

To basically get full retail more or less for your watches in a painless transaction that can be done on the spot in 30 minutes or less? Take it and run before the values go down.

Biggest hassle with anything valuable is selling it hassle free for a good price. You have a chance to be out clean at great prices with zero risk at all, so I would take it right now.

And I wouldn't bother with going grey. You'll still pay more, which is then effectively no different than getting like $30k for your watches at the AD and buying the DD at the AD, not to mention at the end of the day it's still a "used" watch no matter how unworn it is.

Do it all at the AD, and hold out for what you want.