Thoughts on a Trade?

[Harry-57]

Originally Posted by OG1982

I have an offer on the table, it would be a stright swap for the GP and the OP. Yes I have taken a little bit of a hit, but I don't see that ever improving, infact I'd expect the gap to widen.

Sounds like you're about to own an OP. Congratulations.

[OG1982]

Originally Posted by Harry-57

Sounds like you're about to own an OP. Congratulations.

Thank you, the wheels of trade are in motion...

[SLWoodster]

Because of the hype and increased attention in the last 5 years, I actually feel that most all plain Royal Oak and Nautilus desires to be uninteresting and redundant. If that person is a self-professed genta fan, that is a deep rabbit hole. Regurgitating the basics to convince yourself to buy lower priced Nautilus and Royal Oaks is not that interesting.

But this person is going to go back to Rolex no matter what. In the coming years, almost everything will take a bath as compared to Rolex. I think they’ll also venture into preowned to avoid baths.

Originally Posted by Sublovin

I find the GP to be uninteresting. A Genta style watch that isn’t an AP or PP seems redundant and kind of cheap to me. That said, if you love it, keep it. If you are done with it, move on to something you love. This hobby only makes sense if you are wearing what you love. Forget the money, buy and wear what you like. As you said, any gap will not likely get any better.

[~JJ]

No way would I make that trade, would rather have a GP beater than OP at the same price point. To me, it seems like you are too nervous about depreciation and scratching a “nicer” watch, but by trading for an OP you instantly throw away the additional value (real or perceived) and it’s another Oyster variant that will match what you already have. Use the GP to its potential and stop worrying about it.