What is a watch that surprised you? for better or worse

[JEdwardK]

The yachtmaster was never on my radar until I actually saw it in person
the colors really work well together
the rose gold, the matte finish on the bezel, the dial seems to be between black and slate


what's a watch that surprised you, for better or worse?

[Ketler]

The Modern 6 digit Sea Dweller models...

Had all three and sold all three...Didn't like them...

Went back to the 16600...

Can't beat it...


IMG_0009.JPG

[Thetimekeeperr]

Hi there Rolex lovers,

I have been into watches for sometime now & tbh I never thought I’d ever be able to afford one in my life now I’m here learning as much as I can before I venture into the private seller watch world. If anyone has any good advice for me it would be much appreciated

[Gerry62]

Originally Posted by Ketler

The Modern 6 digit Sea Dweller models...

Had all three and sold all three...Didn't like them...

Went back to the 16600...

Can't beat it...


Attachment 1249854

Nice Ketler
I went back to 16600 and sold over time
Deepsea Black and JC Blue, Sub two tone 116613LB Sub 116610 LV Hulk and much more ....

[Sandpit]

Kinda pains me to say it, but the ceramic steel Daytona. A watch I never honestly saw the hype about and I just dismissed it. However I tried one on at a grey dealer and I was actually quite taken aback by it. A lovely lovely watch which felt like perfection on my wrist. Sadly, availability and pricing means I will likely never own one - but that’s ok.

[rlx123]

Originally Posted by Sandpit

Kinda pains me to say it, but the ceramic steel Daytona. A watch I never honestly saw the hype about and I just dismissed it. However I tried one on at a grey dealer and I was actually quite taken aback by it. A lovely lovely watch which felt like perfection on my wrist. Sadly, availability and pricing means I will likely never own one - but that’s ok.

I agree. The black dial in person is very elegant, more so than the white dial.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Harry-57]

For me it was the 16610LV. I'd been admiring them in windows/displays for years and promised myself that if I ever hit a defined goal I would reward myself with this watch.

When the day came to give myself permission to buy it, I was disappointed by the flimsiness of the bracelet, the clasp and the really awful fold out diving extension. Tag were making better bracelets and Omega were on another planet.

Even when it was available to buy at MSRP, I didn't think it was worth the asking price. The 116610LV addressed every issue. When I first saw a photo of the dial I had to look away. But when I saw one for real it instantly became my grail watch. Joint grail to be exact.

First time I saw a Sky Dweller I thought it looked wrong. But it grew on me. Then I found about about the movement, complications, how the dial information was presented and the user friendliness. As I began to gain more knowledge of Rolex design and its history, I started to admire how they has managed to come up with a Classic/Professional hybrid design.

[JSolution]

This … bought as a rotation piece really, because I couldn’t get at sub at retail actually, I thought this was a better deal on the secondary market.

Almost exactly a year later I don’t really wear much else still, It’s perfect.

And that’s coming from someone who prefers gold shiny watches in general :)


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Laostuh]

36MM White Gold Day Date. The size underwhelmed me.

[GMTNYC3790]

Tudor BB58,

Never considered adding a Tudor, but was very comfortable and the dial had me doing double takes.

Love it (especially on a Rubber B band)

[seosub]

Originally Posted by JEdwardK

The yachtmaster was never on my radar until I actually saw it in person
the colors really work well together
the rose gold, the matte finish on the bezel, the dial seems to be between black and slate


what's a watch that surprised you, for better or worse?

This exact watch most of all.

[1995akcoop]

Tudor watches. Was excited to check them out and was very disappointed in how cheesy they look. Ever single model looks like a wannabe Rolex. Some Tudor models look like a mixture of several different Rolex models wrapped into one. I understand there’s a connection between the two brands but Tudors look like something out of Macys.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[sombra]

Originally Posted by 1995akcoop

Tudor watches. Was excited to check them out and was very disappointed in how cheesy they look. Ever single model looks like a wannabe Rolex. Some Tudor models look like a mixture of several different Rolex models wrapped into one. I understand there’s a connection between the two brands but Tudors look like something out of Macys.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

This. All of this.

[Becweb]

Originally Posted by sombra

this. All of this.

+2

[nyc10ken]

Originally Posted by 1995akcoop

Tudor watches. Was excited to check them out and was very disappointed in how cheesy they look. Ever single model looks like a wannabe Rolex. Some Tudor models look like a mixture of several different Rolex models wrapped into one. I understand there’s a connection between the two brands but Tudors look like something out of Macys.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

This is mostly true and I really like Tudors. The Macy's comment cracked me up!

[Schweinwerfer]

Originally Posted by 1995akcoop

Tudor watches. Was excited to check them out and was very disappointed in how cheesy they look. Ever single model looks like a wannabe Rolex. Some Tudor models look like a mixture of several different Rolex models wrapped into one. I understand there’s a connection between the two brands but Tudors look like something out of Macys.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Exactly my thoughts.
The Pelagos was such a huge let down.
Looks great on pictures, though...

[CB66]

Originally Posted by Schweinwerfer

Exactly my thoughts.
The Pelagos was such a huge let down.
Looks great on pictures, though...

Couldn't disagree more. It's an awesome watch. What what were your issues with it?

[Schweinwerfer]

Originally Posted by CB66

Couldn't disagree more. It's an awesome watch. What what were your issues with it?

Too top heavy, disproportionate bracelet (alas too wide and too less taper), the clasp is a league below Rolex and let's not forget to mention that very ugly and seemingly cheap dial.
I was very underwhelmed.

[CB66]

Originally Posted by Schweinwerfer

Too top heavy, disproportionate bracelet (alas too wide and too less taper), the clasp is a league below Rolex and let's not forget to mention that very ugly and seemingly cheap dial.
I was very underwhelmed.

Top heavy is a valid point even though I dont agree (thick but not top heavy). The bracelet is brilliant, I cannot agree with you on the dial. I was mesmerised by its modern design and unbeatable legibility from the first time they were released. It doesn't have to compete with Rolex because its half the price ( more likely a quarter of the price on the pre owned market). But hey, you are entitled to your view.

[nyc10ken]

OF Daytona's, few years back I couldn't fathom getting PM with a rubber strap. But since nobody needed to go back to offices and perhaps rarely dress up ever again, the rubbers are are awesome way to wear and tone down the Daytona's.

Also was never a fan of Royal Oaks until I saw them in person and the way they reflect light.

Nautilus by comparison, underwhelmed me in person given their market price.

[SoylentGreenChi]

Originally Posted by nyc10ken

OF Daytona's, few years back I couldn't fathom getting PM with a rubber strap. But since nobody needed to go back to offices and perhaps rarely dress up ever again, the rubbers are are awesome way to wear and tone down the Daytona's.

Also was never a fan of Royal Oaks until I saw them in person and the way they reflect light.

Nautilus by comparison, underwhelmed me in person given their market price.

I agree with this above, particularly about the Royal Oak. I never considered getting a Royal Oak until I saw one in person, and finally understood their popularity.

Biggest surprise for me though is how much I like the Rolex Wimbledon dial. From photos, I was never drawn to it. Saw it in person on a 36MM Datejust and bought it on the spot. Love it.

[samuel019]

I’d say my 326935. Everything I had hoped for and more. Already had a 326934 in black so I was just expecting a heavier clone but the heft, color, and Chocolate dial blew me away and still does.

Been wearing my Rootbeer for about a week and miss it so as a matter of fact I’m gonna wind her up right now.

[karwath]

The DJ 41, I didn't think I'd want a DJ, but I now have 2.

[seosub]

Originally Posted by karwath

The DJ 41, I didn't think I'd want a DJ, but I now have 2.

Curious how you like that silver dial? Looks very different in some lighting.

[Sandpit]

Originally Posted by seosub

Curious how you like that silver dial? Looks very different in some lighting.

I have the silver DJ36 and love the dial. It’s very much a chameleon. Goes from silver, to white, to champagne and even slightly salmon in certain lights.

[Jpccarguy]

Originally Posted by karwath

The DJ 41, I didn't think I'd want a DJ, but I now have 2.

Maybe the best argument I’ve seen for having two DJ’s. Very different looks. Well played, sir.

[rmlovett1]

Definitely surprised me for the better. Such a sharp watch in person.



Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[TheVTCGuy]

My SkyDweller. One became available at my AD answer I pounced. I wore it for six months and it just was not for me. It’s is a great watch and those of you that own one any congrats But I tried it and found out we didn’t bond.

(Kind of like all the women in my life ).

[1978]

Great thread. For me, SD4K 116600. Fits like a glove, traded my fatboi sub for it and haven’t looked back.

[dannyp]

Explorer 39. Thought at one point (7-8 years ago) it would be my next one. Tried it on and just couldn’t get myself to like the proportions, and I was into bigger watches at the time.