Different take on the polished vs unpolished debate

[Sipper]

I’ve searched buy have not found anything on point. I’m curious is anyone in this forum has ever posted hi def photos of their watch and asked others to guess if the watch is polished or unpolished and then later post revealed the answer. I’d be willing to bet the people who generally hold themselves out as experts would be wrong as often as they are right. I would do it myself buy do not have the ability to take hi def photos.