Thoughts on this trade?

[sportsfan0704]

I have an AP Edward piguet 15121OR, no box no papers that I’m considering trading for a Rolex blusey 16613. Both my watch and the watches I’m looking at are no box no papers. My AP is in good condition, running well, and has the original rose gold pin buckle. It’s a nice piece with Breguet numerals and a cool guilloche dial, but I’m really looking to add the blusey.

Looking at chrono24, there are far far fewer of the Edward piguet for sale than the blusey. The list prices for the AP go between 9 and 14k, whereas the 16613 is between 8500 and 12k. The one I’m looking at is 9500 flat. One dealer told me we would be very far apart on price, which seemed odd given where the market is today and the supply of the submariner both at that dealer and worldwide.

What are everyone’s thoughts on this potential trade? What would be fair for a dealer to ask me to add cash wise to get a deal done?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk