Datejust 41mm 123600 vs panerai 1320

[madmax21]

Somebody made me a straight exchange offer for my day just 41mm. His watch is a 2020 mine is a 2019 both used which watch has the greatest value and is that a fair deal please give me your opinions

[PepsiBezel]

Hard to say without pics, but the trade value of a 126300 is likely more than a Panerai.

[madmax21]

I've been having some problems posting pictures lately on the Rolex forum but what on the form but what I say is that both watches are pretty well bring you my watch has been worn twice in his watches a 2020 with very little wear

[sp5702]

That PAM is a cool piece, but that’s a bad trade.

Edit: purely on value. I think you’d be shorting yourself $1-1.5k potentially.

[ROBERT1183]

I think in the long run the Rolex will hold value way better than the Pam. Its a cool watch but they seem way easier to get.

[hbombkid]

Horrible trade

1-2k difference seems like the Panerai you can get for 7500. Your DJ going for a lot more.

[Seddyspaghetti]

I rather have the sub is my opinion

[Kevin of Larchmont]

He made you this offer because it’s a very good offer for him. I love Panerai and Rolex but the Rolex is a better store of value. Panerai are unlike Rolex in that you can find them pre-owned quite readily and at less than retail, something quite novel after years of owning Rolex. Just buy a Panerai if you want one and keep the Rolex. And in addition I greatly dislike the blue small seconds hand.

[brandrea]

I’d say it’s fair.

The PAM goes for in and around around 10k (CDN for a full set). You might be able to get that privately for your DJ but things aren’t always as they seem and trying sell a watch privately without any previous sales often leads to low ball bids and other pitfalls.

An alternative is to reach out the one of the trusted sellers here and make a trade

[Jack T]

I wouldn't trade any Rolex for any Panerai

[Benzsiam]

It depends on which one you like it better.

If you no longer like DateJust and love to have Panerai, it's worth it.

For long term I think Rolex retain better value.

[TswaneNguni]

Originally Posted by Jack T

I wouldn't trade any Rolex for any Panerai

I would trade many of my Rolex for a PAM127,pristine and complete set .Absolutely !

I just cant find it in my part of the woods and import taxes and VAT makes it expensive...

[Shazbot302]

Never! Never be seen in public with a Pan.

[DoctorA]

Look at the classified section to get an idea but your DJ is about $1.5k-$2k more

[Kevin of Larchmont]

Originally Posted by Shazbot302

Never! Never be seen in public with a Pan.

Just for that I took off my Explorer II and put on my PAM 111 and now I’m going shopping

[Oxfordian]

Originally Posted by Kevin of Larchmont

Just for that I took off my Explorer II and put on my PAM 111 and now I’m going shopping

Good man, give that PAM a bit of wrist time

[Jack T]

Originally Posted by TswaneNguni

I would trade many of my Rolex for a PAM127,pristine and complete set .Absolutely !

I just cant find it in my part of the woods and import taxes and VAT makes it expensive...

Guess I don’t know enough about Panerai. They tend to be on the large size for me, and while a few that I’ve seen are appealing, not enough to trade one of my Rolex’s.