Batgirl vs Sub vs DJ41

[ukwatchguy1]

Hi all, hope everyone is well,

I know I love these type of comparison posts! But hear me out on the following if possible looking for opinions:

Currently have a 2024 Batgirl, but I feel in todays world the GMT function is a bit obsolete, I never use it anyway, but was initially attracted to it as a blend of submariner and DJ in one.

Considering the below options and welcome your thoughts, it would be a one and done watch, apart from my Apple Watch, which can be worn for rough stuff

- Keep batgirl

- change back to a submariner 41mm date - more of a classic look compared to GMT I feel less complication and potentially will stand test of time better than a GMT Batgirl

- Submariner 41mm Kermit mk2 bezel, previously owned a mk1, but the mk2 is more of a unique bezel, not just lifted off the old hulk

- Datejust 41mm mint green, jubilee and fluted bezel. More dressy, Apple Watch for most the time and DJ for the nicer times - Batgirl is neither really an out and out sports watch nor a dress watch I feel kind of sits in the middle

I know I’ll get blasted in the comments for thinking of changing again etc but I just want to sort it for good and then maybe have some time off the forum!

[dmash]

Sub MK2 Starbucks

[JRell]

I have owned many including subs and datejusts. The BLNR on jubilee truly combines the two most popular Rolex into one watch. I tried to go back to just the black sub date but it was way too boring compared to the BLNR. I would keep and add the Sublv. I will probably get the LV again, I had them both and it is a fantastic duo. But don’t dare get rid of the BLNR, you will regret it as I did. It is the perfect watch.

[garyk]

Originally Posted by JRell

I have owned many including subs and datejusts. The BLNR on jubilee truly combines the two most popular Rolex into one watch. I tried to go back to just the black sub date but it was way too boring compared to the BLNR. I would keep and add the Sublv. I will probably get the LV again, I had them both and it is a fantastic duo. But don’t dare get rid of the BLNR, you will regret it as I did. It is the perfect watch.

[996marty]

I’d keep the Batgirl tbh I don’t see the point in switching it out as for me it’s a great reference

[Belinus]

I have a BLNR, Sub Date and DJ41. The BLNR is newest so I’m wearing it a lot but I love it. I’m out the country just now and the GMT function has been great albeit I had to go into the local Rolex shop to get it set properly! I love my Sub Date too as an everyday watch. The one I will wear least will be the DJ41, beautiful watch but less me.

Edit: I had an Apple Watch but didn’t see the point. I use my phone if I need anything. Would much rather have a “real” watch on my wrist

[Krash]

I have all three. I’d never get rid of a GMT BLNR and replace it with a DJ. Not in a million years. To be clear, that doesn’t mean I dislike my DJ41. Quite the contrary, I love it.

But the Submariner is a different story altogether. If I could only have one watch, I’m not sure which one I would choose.

Also, in terms of the GMT being neither a dress watch or a sport watch, I think you’re overthinking it. I wouldn’t worry about it. I swim with mine all the time. I wouldn’t hesitate wearing it with a suit either. One thing for sure, I do think the BLNR is more special than the Sub, FWIW.

BTW, I have an Apple Watch, too. That’s what I wear when I’m bike riding and working out at the gym.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Hulkhunter]

You say the GMT function is obsolete but are you planning on diving to 300m in the near future?

Any of the 3 can be a one and done. Don’t worry about the functionality just go with the one that you like the look of. I’d keep what you have if I was you. Then maybe look to add one of the others down the line. Or even get the oyster bracelet to go along with the jubilee.

[brandrea]

The clear answer is that you need to ADD the Submariner

[B2 Stealth]

As a commercial airline pilot I am constantly using the GMT function like thousands of pilots have before me. The GMT combines best attributes of Sub and DJ in one watch. I do enjoy my Sub LV but the GMT is my all-time favorite watch.

[travisb]

For a one and done my choice would always be a Sub of some sort.
The Sub LV ticks all the boxes with the classic Sub look with a little color to keep things interesting.

[samson66]

Well you can time things with a GMT watch, but you can't track multiple timezones with a diver. Stick with the BLNR

And I'll mail you a dollar if you stop calling it batgirl