Which GMT Master 2 to choose?

[LuvThatDing]

Hi guys,

I'm in the market for the GMT Master 2 and torn between two options.
What would you do in this situation?.

- 16710 Pepsi New Old Stock with full stickers, Serif Bezel, Full-set (Around $15K-16K)
- 126710 Pepsi, Full-set (Around $19K-20K)

These are two different watches with $3K-4K price gap.
I really love both versions, but can't make a decision

[Roddypeepa]

I would buy the modern reference.

I think the premium for the NoS is pretty heavy here - a used one would be maybe 2/3 to half of that.

That being said neo vintage is appealing in its own way. If you get hands on with both you will know.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Reinhard in SA]

Originally Posted by LuvThatDing

Hi guys,

I'm in the market for the GMT Master 2 and torn between two options.
What would you do in this situation?.

- 16710 Pepsi New Old Stock with full stickers, Serif Bezel, Full-set (Around $15K-16K)
- 126710 Pepsi, Full-set (Around $19K-20K)

These are two different watches with $3K-4K price gap.
I really love both versions, but can't make a decision

I own both and my vote is the 16710.

[brandrea]

Although they are both BLROs they are two very different watches.

Are you able to try them on to see which one you prefer? They wear completely differently

[travisb]

There's no right or wrong answer.
New 6 digit for me.
Both are fantastic but I prefer the way the modern GMT wears and feels.

[padi56]

Originally Posted by LuvThatDing

Hi guys,

I'm in the market for the GMT Master 2 and torn between two options.
What would you do in this situation?.

- 16710 Pepsi New Old Stock with full stickers, Serif Bezel, Full-set (Around $15K-16K)
- 126710 Pepsi, Full-set (Around $19K-20K)

These are two different watches with $3K-4K price gap.
I really love both versions, but can't make a decision

Not a fan of any of the ceramic range of Rolex watches so would choose any 16710 very versatile watch get all 3 inserts then 3 different watches for little money.

[BellaAbzug1]

Choosing a Rolex GMT-Master II depends on your style and preference. The "Pepsi" with its red and blue bezel offers a classic look, while the "Batman" with a black and blue bezel adds a modern touch. For luxury, the "Root Beer" with its gold accents is a standout choice.

[mailman]

It’ll be easier to find a 126710 in the future opposed to an NOS 16710.

If only one I’d take the 126710.

[rmlovett1]

For me ….it'd be a matter of what’s in the collection already. If I had all modern, I MIGHT consider the 5 digit, that’s a big maybe , as I love the modern reference on jubilee.
If it were a one and only watch….6 digit for sure.

[1William]

NOS pricing is reflective of the fact that it has not been worn. If you are going to wear the watch, I would not take the value hit and would look preowned. As far as the choice between the older model and the newer model I would go with the the current model on jubilee. Costs a bit more but to me it is worth it. If you want something that has a vintage look then go with a Tudor Black Bay GMT. Put it on a five link bracelet, leather or NATO. All for around 3k pre-owned. So I would/did the same thing. Modern BLRO and the Tudor. I am pleased with the watches.

[Dan Pierce]

Originally Posted by padi56

Not a fan of any of the ceramic range of Rolex watches so would choose any 16710 very versatile watch get all 3 inserts then 3 different watches for little money.

^ This. Throw in a jubilee and you have opened up even more options.
dP