Batgirl vs Sub vs DJ41

[ukwatchguy1]

Hi all, hope everyone is well,

I know I love these type of comparison posts! But hear me out on the following if possible looking for opinions:

Currently have a 2024 Batgirl, but I feel in todays world the GMT function is a bit obsolete, I never use it anyway, but was initially attracted to it as a blend of submariner and DJ in one.

Considering the below options and welcome your thoughts, it would be a one and done watch, apart from my Apple Watch, which can be worn for rough stuff

- Keep batgirl

- change back to a submariner 41mm date - more of a classic look compared to GMT I feel less complication and potentially will stand test of time better than a GMT Batgirl

- Submariner 41mm Kermit mk2 bezel, previously owned a mk1, but the mk2 is more of a unique bezel, not just lifted off the old hulk

- Datejust 41mm mint green, jubilee and fluted bezel. More dressy, Apple Watch for most the time and DJ for the nicer times - Batgirl is neither really an out and out sports watch nor a dress watch I feel kind of sits in the middle

I know I’ll get blasted in the comments for thinking of changing again etc but I just want to sort it for good and then maybe have some time off the forum!

[dmash]

Sub MK2 Starbucks

[JRell]

I have owned many including subs and datejusts. The BLNR on jubilee truly combines the two most popular Rolex into one watch. I tried to go back to just the black sub date but it was way too boring compared to the BLNR. I would keep and add the Sublv. I will probably get the LV again, I had them both and it is a fantastic duo. But don’t dare get rid of the BLNR, you will regret it as I did. It is the perfect watch.

[garyk]

Originally Posted by JRell

I have owned many including subs and datejusts. The BLNR on jubilee truly combines the two most popular Rolex into one watch. I tried to go back to just the black sub date but it was way too boring compared to the BLNR. I would keep and add the Sublv. I will probably get the LV again, I had them both and it is a fantastic duo. But don’t dare get rid of the BLNR, you will regret it as I did. It is the perfect watch.

[996marty]

I’d keep the Batgirl tbh I don’t see the point in switching it out as for me it’s a great reference

[Belinus]

I have a BLNR, Sub Date and DJ41. The BLNR is newest so I’m wearing it a lot but I love it. I’m out the country just now and the GMT function has been great albeit I had to go into the local Rolex shop to get it set properly! I love my Sub Date too as an everyday watch. The one I will wear least will be the DJ41, beautiful watch but less me.

Edit: I had an Apple Watch but didn’t see the point. I use my phone if I need anything. Would much rather have a “real” watch on my wrist

[Krash]

I have all three. I’d never get rid of a GMT BLNR and replace it with a DJ. Not in a million years. To be clear, that doesn’t mean I dislike my DJ41. Quite the contrary, I love it.

But the Submariner is a different story altogether. If I could only have one watch, I’m not sure which one I would choose.

Also, in terms of the GMT being neither a dress watch or a sport watch, I think you’re overthinking it. I wouldn’t worry about it. I swim with mine all the time. I wouldn’t hesitate wearing it with a suit either. One thing for sure, I do think the BLNR is more special than the Sub, FWIW.

BTW, I have an Apple Watch, too. That’s what I wear when I’m bike riding and working out at the gym.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Hulkhunter]

You say the GMT function is obsolete but are you planning on diving to 300m in the near future?

Any of the 3 can be a one and done. Don’t worry about the functionality just go with the one that you like the look of. I’d keep what you have if I was you. Then maybe look to add one of the others down the line. Or even get the oyster bracelet to go along with the jubilee.

[brandrea]

The clear answer is that you need to ADD the Submariner

[B2 Stealth]

As a commercial airline pilot I am constantly using the GMT function like thousands of pilots have before me. The GMT combines best attributes of Sub and DJ in one watch. I do enjoy my Sub LV but the GMT is my all-time favorite watch.

[travisb]

For a one and done my choice would always be a Sub of some sort.
The Sub LV ticks all the boxes with the classic Sub look with a little color to keep things interesting.

[samson66]

Well you can time things with a GMT watch, but you can't track multiple timezones with a diver. Stick with the BLNR

And I'll mail you a dollar if you stop calling it batgirl

[Db9506]

I have all three amongst others.

21 Sub Date, 22 GMT Batgirl and a 24 DJ41 Azzurro.

I'd take the sub and the DJ as a 2 watch combo, if pressed for a 1 watch combo would take the Batgirl and buy an oyster as well so can tone it down a bit if necessary. I've also got a blue rubber B style band for the GMT which would look a good beach watch if necessary.

To answer your question, I'd keep the Batgirl and source an oyster bracelet as well so you can mix it up. 2 maybe 3 watches in one.

Cheers

[Bazil]

GMT, all day, any day ..

[APhound]

It’s always fun to change up watches. I’d actually take a DJ if I were you then get something else next year or whenever you want to change up again. None of these need to be a forever watch


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[fly4food84]

Wouldn’t even think about a DJ.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[exp90]

Without any doubt, add the Sub and keep the BLNR!! You will not regret this way.

[ukwatchguy1]

Thanks for the replies everyone, it has helped me remove the DJ from my mind! Now the question if staying GMT if the Pepsi is better?!

[JRell]

Originally Posted by ukwatchguy1

Thanks for the replies everyone, it has helped me remove the DJ from my mind! Now the question if staying GMT if the Pepsi is better?!

Who said the BLRO is better? The real question is do you like black and blue or blue and red. Then you pick accordingly.

[1William]

I would keep the BLNR and add a Submariner ND. A very good two watch collection.

[ukwatchguy1]

True, not saying Pepsi is “better” but i was probably persuaded by hype!

The sub date in my eyes is a real out and out classic and with the glidelock comfort that is nice too

But on same note the gmt being that bit smaller plus jubilee it’s comfy but hard to get bang in fitment with the easy link compared to glidelock

I’ve wasted a lot of money going back and forth on watches and just need to weigh up whether to go back to a black sub with a bit of money my way or stick as I am… I can only have one watch,

[TheVision]

Hmm...for me, its the other way around. I use the gmt on my Panerai almost daily (also my vacation watch). I work with healtcare vendors in Denmark so have that as my 2nd timezone on my Panerai gmt. When I'm on vacation, I set the gmt hand to reflect my home time. I was in Bali and Vietnam back in July and gmt was super handy.

I own the sub date and never use the bezel for any timing. To be honest, I got bored with the black monotone look. I've been wearing my blue dial Pam far more.

Ironically, I'm now on the waitlist for batman/girl. Once I get it, I'll sell my Pam and use the batman as a daily driver.

[saltyandwet]

Originally Posted by ukwatchguy1

Hi all, hope everyone is well,

I know I love these type of comparison posts! But hear me out on the following if possible looking for opinions:

Currently have a 2024 Batgirl, but I feel in todays world the GMT function is a bit obsolete, I never use it anyway, but was initially attracted to it as a blend of submariner and DJ in one.

Considering the below options and welcome your thoughts, it would be a one and done watch, apart from my Apple Watch, which can be worn for rough stuff

- Keep batgirl

- change back to a submariner 41mm date - more of a classic look compared to GMT I feel less complication and potentially will stand test of time better than a GMT Batgirl

- Submariner 41mm Kermit mk2 bezel, previously owned a mk1, but the mk2 is more of a unique bezel, not just lifted off the old hulk

- Datejust 41mm mint green, jubilee and fluted bezel. More dressy, Apple Watch for most the time and DJ for the nicer times - Batgirl is neither really an out and out sports watch nor a dress watch I feel kind of sits in the middle

I know I’ll get blasted in the comments for thinking of changing again etc but I just want to sort it for good and then maybe have some time off the forum!

By your rationale, then aren't all mechanical watches "obsolete"? Who really uses their mechanical wrist watch to tell time?

[Mystro]

You’re bored and you want something new. Slow your roll and don’t do anything. Always looking for that “new watch” feel is only ever temporary. Use the GMT bezel like a timer and you don’t need a Sub. You already own the best GMT.

[worldofoyster]

the batgirl is quite nice