Patek 5296R (Non-Sector) vs ALS 1815 Manual Wind

[msimm30]

Hi all,

I will be graduating university in several months and am seeking advice regarding which watch I should choose as a graduation gift (in combination with saved money). The idea is to have a nice dress watch that will be suitable for formal dress and business occasions.

I have narrowed down my choices between the 5296R Calatrava and the Lange 1815 Manual Wind (in rose gold) but am having a tough time deciding which watch will be the one; I love the arabic numerals and pocket watch look of the Lange but the Patek is classically understated and pedigreed.





The Patek could be acquired from a local AD for $22K but something about the Lange's case keeps bringing me back to it. The lack of Lange at my local AD would cause a need to go to a new AD to try and negotiate an already expensive watch from a scratch.

What is the deal with Lange AD/Boutiques (possibly Wempe NYC) and negotiating prices? What is the maximum discount one can usually expect for Lange watches? I am also drawn to the new Saxonia Moonphase, but that would be a bit too expensive; I am interested to see how much the dealer can be worked down--maybe this watch is somewhat within reach.




What watch would you personally choose, and why? Any other suggestions within the price range are also much appreciated, thanks!