Service plexi vs aftermarket?

[thenewguyguys]

Which plexi is the "best" one? I got a service plexi on my 5513. Would a aftermarket lets say from MY be as safe as a service plexi(thinking about bringing it in water etc?)

[jdog111578]

If fitted correctly, his would be one of the few I would trust. You are always going to be better off going OEM i.e. Rolex, but Michael knows what he is doing and produces a quality product. Keep in mind as well, once fit and pressure tested properly, I would never remove a crystal and then reinsert too many times as they develop micro-cracks and can fail.

[Tools]

Originally Posted by thenewguyguys

Which plexi is the "best" one? I got a service plexi on my 5513. Would a aftermarket lets say from MY be as safe as a service plexi(thinking about bringing it in water etc?)

If your watchmaker uses one of the many brand name, quality crystals available for your model, and installs it properly, it will be as water-tight as any other.

[swish77]

Proceed with extreme caution with aftermarket crystals. I've been through a nightmare trying to use them. Read my post on this old thread below about the topic. I only ever use Rolex crystals now. Good luck either way.

https://www.rolexforums.com/showthread.php?t=313971

[belligero]

Originally Posted by swish77

Proceed with extreme caution with aftermarket crystals. I've been through a nightmare trying to use them. Read my post on this old thread below about the topic. I only ever use Rolex crystals now. Good luck either way.

https://www.rolexforums.com/showthread.php?t=313971

Agreed; stick to original Rolex parts, especially for something as critical as a crystal. "Suffering for fashion" comes to mind with using off-brand ones just for the look.

[Kingface66]

FWIW, I recently had one of Michael Young's T19s installed on my 1680 (it arrived from Hong Kong in only a few days, and was able to be installed that afternoon). It was pressure tested, and passed. So, so far, no complaints...and it looks pretty great.
Here are a few pics of the crystal (flanked boy a photo of some boy band from Liverpool)

[Vincent65]

Originally Posted by Kingface66

FWIW, I recently had one of Michael Young's T19s installed on my 1680 (it arrived from Hong Kong in only a few days, and was able to be installed that afternoon). It was pressure tested, and passed. So, so far, no complaints...and it looks pretty great.
Here are a few pics of the crystal (flanked boy a photo of some boy band from Liverpool)

That looks great - just had a look at their site and there's only 1 available under 'crystals' for $250 - I doubt any aftermarket plastic dome is 250 bucks...

"ROLEX 5513 REPLACEMENT CRYSTAL

250.00"

Where are the copies?

[swish77]

Originally Posted by Kingface66

FWIW, I recently had one of Michael Young's T19s installed on my 1680 (it arrived from Hong Kong in only a few days, and was able to be installed that afternoon). It was pressure tested, and passed. So, so far, no complaints...and it looks pretty great.
Here are a few pics of the crystal (flanked boy a photo of some boy band from Liverpool)

Keep an eye on it over time. The original Rolex crystals last for years, and sometimes decades. I don't have experience with MY crystals, but any aftermarket crystals would make me nervous.

[seattleal]

Originally Posted by Kingface66

FWIW, I recently had one of Michael Young's T19s installed on my 1680 (it arrived from Hong Kong in only a few days, and was able to be installed that afternoon). It was pressure tested, and passed. So, so far, no complaints...and it looks pretty great.
Here are a few pics of the crystal (flanked boy a photo of some boy band from Liverpool)

I too have used his T-19 on my 5512, it also passed a pressure test and I like it very much- here is a pic:

[hkforyou]

MY ..one...i repleced 3 times at his shop for my 7928