HELP! Rolex newbie who got a call from the AD for a watch, not sure if I should pull

[Calatrava r]

Originally Posted by Nikrnic

'My' short answer is No X 4. Don't rush it, take a little more time. It doesn't sound like you really want it anyway.

Sent from my SM-G970U using Tapatalk

I did not sense a passion for this watch either.

[904VT]

If you’re just starting your career both watches are too expensive now unless you’re well above 6 figures annually. Save longer and really think about what you want. Just my opinion

[MilesB]

The Root Beer is a more interesting piece. The Sub is a classic, but they are everywhere. If you want something to mark a milestone, go for the different piece, get the Root Beer.

[comanndr]

don't buy a watch that doesn't sing to you
it will cost you more in the long run
all my watches i can't stand to take off
you've had a lot of good advice
good luck mate
regards

[DBlue2018]

I’d avoid a normal sub as I’d hazard a guess that the majority of them you see are fakes

The root beer is far rarer and I’d jump on it

[Parapraxis]

Thank you all for the responses. I'm reading a lot more "don't get it" responses than I expected. Looks like I'm giving the impression that I don't like the watch and that I'm jumping on it because it's available. Which I didn't think I was doing, but if you've all felt that way from my post, maybe I need to evaluate that further.

A good question raised here is which do I like more: sub or root beer? And honestly, I don't LOVE the submariner, it just made sense cognitively for it to be my first watch (price, versatility and easily recognized as a Rolex).

If I were to able remove all the noise (hype, scarcity, appreciation potential, price) and I had the two watches infront of me; I would say the root beer is a watch I find better looking. Not sure if that should play into my decision?

[Hollie_Rollie]

I would take the offer!

[Burlington]

If you’re just buying into the brand for peer recognition then the two tone would get spotted more readily.

[logo]

Originally Posted by Parapraxis

Thank you all for the responses. I'm reading a lot more "don't get it" responses than I expected. Looks like I'm giving the impression that I don't like the watch and that I'm jumping on it because it's available. Which I didn't think I was doing, but if you've all felt that way from my post, maybe I need to evaluate that further.

A good question raised here is which do I like more: sub or root beer? And honestly, I don't LOVE the submariner, it just made sense cognitively for it to be my first watch (price, versatility and easily recognized as a Rolex).

If I were to able remove all the noise (hype, scarcity, appreciation potential, price) and I had the two watches infront of me; I would say the root beer is a watch I find better looking. Not sure if that should play into my decision?

I think the real question is removing hype, removing any watches in front of you currently, removing whatever people here tell you, what would you actually like to wear?

If you’re set on Rolex, that’s fine but don’t try and cognitively rationalize a purchase for a Rolex - it’s an irrational non-essential luxury item. Most here buy because they like it (not all...) but it’s very easy to get sucked into hype and end up buying something based on what others think you should have.

For reference, I have a two tone datejust - far from a “hot” Instagram model, but I wouldn’t trade it for any Daytona/Pepsi/etc because I bought it because I liked it best. Will it hold value? Reasonably, and certainly not to the extent that a Daytona would, but frankly I don’t care because it’s not going to be up for sale. Is the gold worth it? Strictly speaking the extra cost for the two tone model is more than the price of gold (so no not “worth” it’s cost in gold), but to me personally I put “worth” on it because the extra cost gets me what I wanted.

[EndlessEight]

The root beer is an amazing watch.

If it’s going to be your only Rolex for a while I wouldn’t buy it and stay focused on the Sub.

[garyk]

Take it, never look the gift horse in the mouth! Seems like you have an opportunity to obtain a unique piece in a sea of not very many opportunities. Seriously, you cant go wrong...Good luck!!!

[franktehtank]

The root beer GMT is a beautiful watch. It's also quite different from a steel submariner. Only you can decide if it will satiate your craving for a sub or not.

I laugh at the people on here saying no one respects a sub. The sub is still the King of Rolex. It's the brand's most iconic watch. Too much time spent on internet forums, I think.

If I could only have one Rolex, or one watch for that matter, it'd be a steel black dial sub date. No pepsi, daytona, batman, hulk, etc (and I love all those watches), gimme a good ol' sub!

[danyvw]

Originally Posted by Parapraxis

Thank you all for the responses. I'm reading a lot more "don't get it" responses than I expected. Looks like I'm giving the impression that I don't like the watch and that I'm jumping on it because it's available. Which I didn't think I was doing, but if you've all felt that way from my post, maybe I need to evaluate that further.



A good question raised here is which do I like more: sub or root beer? And honestly, I don't LOVE the submariner, it just made sense cognitively for it to be my first watch (price, versatility and easily recognized as a Rolex).



If I were to able remove all the noise (hype, scarcity, appreciation potential, price) and I had the two watches infront of me; I would say the root beer is a watch I find better looking. Not sure if that should play into my decision?

You answered your own question. Forget about the hype and other BS. If you like it, BUY IT.

Sent from my SM-T720 using Tapatalk

[comanndr]

if the root beer sings /talks to you etc
then its settled

[Harry-57]

Originally Posted by Parapraxis

Thank you all for the responses. I'm reading a lot more "don't get it" responses than I expected. Looks like I'm giving the impression that I don't like the watch and that I'm jumping on it because it's available. Which I didn't think I was doing, but if you've all felt that way from my post, maybe I need to evaluate that further.

A good question raised here is which do I like more: sub or root beer? And honestly, I don't LOVE the submariner, it just made sense cognitively for it to be my first watch (price, versatility and easily recognized as a Rolex).

If I were to able remove all the noise (hype, scarcity, appreciation potential, price) and I had the two watches infront of me; I would say the root beer is a watch I find better looking. Not sure if that should play into my decision?

I think you just answered you own question again!

If what you say applied to my situation I would be a CHNR owner in the very near future.

As it happens, I should be. I love this watch. I think it's the equal most stylish and visually clever TT watch Rolex make, along with the Blusey. Mine should be along any month now.

All the best with it.

[Setarip]

So many good posts with great advice here. Nothing more to add really - other than to affirm, “buy the watch that sings to you” If you fall in love with the CHNR after trying it on buy regardless (assuming you can afford it). Otherwise, pass and wait for the SS Sub.

I walked away from a CHNR and SS Skydweller a few weeks ago because neither appeals to me and I wouldn’t want to buy a watch just because it’s hard to find / get when I know the AD has a long list of guys who REALLY want those watches. (and I would never consider flipping!).

[Bob the brush]

I would buy a CHNR over a sub any day of the week, I have a LN version and its an absolutely fantastic bit of kit, I love it!

[Tools]

Originally Posted by Parapraxis

. . .

If I were to able remove all the noise (hype, scarcity, appreciation potential, price) and I had the two watches infront of me; I would say the root beer is a watch I find better looking. Not sure if that should play into my decision?

I think that the TT black GMT and the TT black Sub Date are the best looking watch "look" that Rolex ever produced; I have both.

If you do lean towards the chocolate version GMT, nobody is going to question your decision, plenty here have chosen this watch over others.

Most folks give opinion that is their preference, not yours.

[Parapraxis]

Originally Posted by EndlessEight

The root beer is an amazing watch.

If it’s going to be your only Rolex for a while I wouldn’t buy it and stay focused on the Sub.

If it's good, why not have it as my only Rolex for a while?

[jaisonline]

The modern GMT Root Beer is rose gold and stainless steel. That is a lot of cash to spend on a watch that mighy not be likely suitable for everyday wear unless you will.

If you really like the Root Beer (regardless if you like it as an everyday watch) why not go for a 2-tone SS / YG 16713 with the brown dial? That resembles the original and more iconic Root Beer that Clint Eastwood help make popular. 16713s from the early 2000s go for less than $10k USD. Save a ton of cash.

Random pic below is from Google...

[reddog4063]

Right now everything is hot but historically TT does not hold value well, keep that in mind.

That being said, the sub is the s-class of watches. Youre paying alot to see yourself coming and going. The rootbeer is a far MOre interesting choice for a budding WIS.

[jaisonline]

Originally Posted by reddog4063

Right now everything is hot but historically TT does not hold value well, keep that in mind.



That being said, the sub is the s-class of watches. Youre paying alot to see yourself coming and going. The rootbeer is a far MOre interesting choice for a budding WIS.

Exactly. I wouldn’t ever pay MSRP for a 2-tone watch. When the economy eventually goes south, 6-digit 2-tone watches will be among to first to take a hit.

The 5-digit 2-tone has been retired for a long time and will take a less hit (if any). Plus, the case isn’t the super-case version and screams “ look at me”.

Just my opinion that wasn’t asked for :)

[jjfesq]

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[jjfesq]

If I could only get one right now it’s the White Sky. It’s just a little more than msrp Grey. It’s a professional watch that doubles as a dress watch.
If the $ is available I’d look for a Blue Yellow gold sub. You can find them very discounted, And you don’t run into them coming and going.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[EP32k2]

If the CHNR was never on your radar then forget it. Pretty simple actually lol

[dwjez14]

Wait for the sub. I think you will enjoy it more. Being a newbie get something that is a classic. Now I know the root beer is a great new piece but a sub and a datejust perhaps most would agree are more iconic and timeless models. Especially being a new guy you might be better off getting a sub for the bracelet since it doesn’t show scratches that easy. The gold on the root beer scratches very easy on them which being a new Rolex guy may bother you. Just be patient and for the first model get only what you want. Worst case go gray with davidsw or timepiece Gentleman if you don’t want to wait. Good luck and hope you find one soon.

[JonaG]

Originally Posted by Wood&Leather

lol. can't readily answer which i see more of, black dial submariners or canada goose jackets.

Lol. Half the women I see are wearing those jackets and it’s like 10oC!

[dwjez14]

Do not and I repeat do not buy this watch just to set yourself up for another watch in the future. That backfires for many on this forum. I did the same thing 2 years not one watch from my top 3 on wish list from my AD

[EndlessEight]

Originally Posted by Parapraxis

If it's good, why not have it as my only Rolex for a while?

In my opinion it’s not as versatile (dress to casual ratio).

If you disagree. Go for it!

Adding pics as well.




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Dr.LJ]

If you like it, buy it. Otherwise don't.

On value retention, usually you are more likely to take a hit with TT compared to SS.