5712/1A or 5960p-016 (black dial)

[shahuk]

Hi all -

I've decided to trade my 5167A (my only Patek, acquired below msrp in 2015) and my 116170BLNR (acquired at msrp last year) towards a grail piece.

Although not a huge fan of the 5711 I love the quirky dial of the 5712. I've also always loved the opaline black dial of the 5960p-016 and the fact it was only made for 1 year is cool. I can honestly say I'm equally enamoured!

Both are available to me through a (grey) trade, but I can only get one (economics are almost identical). Whichever one I pick, it will be babied/special occasion watch. Which would it be for you? Any thoughts appreciated!