Daytona value lots of use vs clean

[jw72]

Hello,
I am ready to pull the trigger on a Black face Daytona.
What would you buy?
2002 Y Rolex Daytona, Box papers (USA) ect for 16,500. The issue is it has a lot of use last 15 years.
Or
Very slightly/30-90 days used 2003 F, sticker on back, Box papers (german papers) for 18,500.
Both are small hands.
Is it a waste of 2K to buy the same watch just no use on it?
Both are the same seller
Thank you