For you mid-size experts, which one would you keep?

[goodtrader]

For all you mid-size enthusiasts out there, I need your help in determining which one of these I should keep. If you had to chose one...

1). Royal, "Shockresistant", "Super Oyster" crown - 6144, Case# 807***
2). Royallite, 24 Hour Dial, "Oyster Patent" crown - 2280, Case# 129***

So it would help a lot if any of you could tell which dials are original (if any) and which watch is more rare... Thanks / Cheers!