Nautilus 5711, 5712 or AP 15202 ST, 15400ST, or 15300 ST

[sirish19]

Hi All,

I posted a similar question on the PP forum and most recommend the Nautilus for my collection but thought I would throw it out here on the AP forum as well to get a different perspective.

My current collection is below. I am considering flipping the PAM and adding another watch to the collection. After getting my Patrimony and PP Annual Calendar, the PAM is just too big and bulky. I have decided to add another SS watch on a bracelet to give me another alternative to the GMT II during the hot summer months and something that can go casual or with a suit. I also think a blue dial would fit well with my collection so am considering either the Nautilus or Royal Oak.

Given my current collection, which do you guys think would be a better fit, Nautilus or RO? Factors I am considering are also availability, price, resale value, service cost, etc.

For those recommending the RO, can you tell me why you would recommend one over the other? Thanks for your input.