5711/1r vs 5712/1a vs 5726/1a

[Roovain]

Dear Ahfe:
Here's my take on your dilemma. First and foremost, you have to realize that there's quite a difference between the two thin Nautilus's (5711 and 5712) vs. the 5726. The latter is quite beefier and more substantial, while the former two are very flat. Personally, I like the "meatier" 5726, since I don't wear dress shirts (I'm a surgeon; I wear scrubs and golf shirts). But the point is that people don't normally buy a pair of pants, or a pair of sunglasses, or buy a car WITHOUT trying it/them on first. Right? So before you make your decision, you need to find a way to try on these models before making a commitment. Here's an example: I fell in love with the 5140 series of watches, and was all set to get the platinum version. Then I tried it on, and instantly realized that it just didn't fit right, and was actually too small on my wrist. Sure glad I tried it on, first. Here's another point: To me, taking the leap into the Patek world implies getting a watch with their famous annual or perpetual calendar complications. If I wanted to set the date five times a year, I'd get a Rolex or Omega. Capiche? I could tell you I'd vote for the 5726...but that wouldn't do you any good. You have to try them on first.