Need your advice...trade a 5296G for a 5107G?

[glimmer]

Hi all- I wanted to get the opinions of the members here.

I am currently thinking about trading my 5296G Sector Dial for a 5107G.

I just got the 5296G a few weeks ago and I don’t seem to be bonding with it. I’m not sure if it would take some time (as some of my other watches take) before it grows on me but for the moment I find it a bit too plain.

I used to own a 5107G and sold it off for a succession of Calatravas (and a brief flirtation with the Aquanaut) but the 5107G always had a place in my heart. I love the sinuous curves and the crown guards as well as the “glow,” if you will, of the Rhodium plated white gold.

I have a chance to trade my 5296G for the 5107 but I’m not sure yet if I need to give the 5296 more time. I feel the 5296G may fit my relatively casual daily attire better than the 5107, but I have other watches that could also do the job.

With the recent discontinuation of the 5296 I am thinking that it may bode well for me to keep it for the moment, though.
Any thoughts on the relative value of both? The 5296G is from 2013 and the 5107 is from 2005.

Do you guys think a straight trade would be fair?

Any thoughts would be much appreciated. Here are some photos of my 5296 and my dear departed 5107.






Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk