Should I entertain this trade???

[TommyT53]

Who in there right mind would trade the gold GMT C 116718 for the PP 5711/1A blue dial??.

[kilyung]

Me. Although having both is better.

[mikeceee]

I wouldn't. Not a fan of plain dial Nautilus. Much prefer 5726

[tkerrmd]

Originally Posted by TommyT53

Who in there right mind would trade the gold GMT C 116718 for the PP 5711/1A blue dial??.

Not me, like the gold

[viper9669]

No sir.

[sturgeon123456]

No sir GMT is a beaut. PP nice, just not as aesthetically pleasing to me but......go with your gut

[CWIN]

I'd do the trade if the GMT were purchased preowned at a substantial discount. I prefer the Nautilus to the GMT even in precious metal.

[AK797]

Originally Posted by tkerrmd

Not me, like the gold

Me neither. A full gold bracelet is too much to give up unless the PP is RG too such as a 5167r or 5712r and even then I would probably need to have another gold Rolex in the locker.

[GB-man]

I would without blinking. Not ready for full gold Preference for white metal here.

[watchwatcher]

i don't know...it's more of a question of what you like. While I'm a huge fan of the 116718, I can understand how some would be attracted to the Patek.

I would entertain this trade...not sure if I would do it, but I would entertain it...

[derekstlmo]

I would do that trade

[alubin]

Its a fair trade. Very different watches though.

[Daytonaman799]

5712 1/a yes...5711...a much harder call.

[aleeboy]

I agree that it's a fair trade in terms of value, BUT I would not do it as I much prefer a precious metal Rolex than a SS Patek.

[1995akcoop]

not me...... not a PP fan, aesthetically

[Manofsteelpt]

Yup, trade away :-)

[brandrea]

That's a tough call. Having tried the 5711 recently, I have to say I'd lean that way! Very different pieces as mentioned already.

[jjnd08]

Not a chance.

[oldbronco]

Originally Posted by GB-man

I would without blinking. Not ready for full gold Preference for white metal here.

+1. quality wise, any Patek is better IMHO. I own both brands.

[bobernet]

No, thanks. Prefer the gold crown.

[Daytona4130]

Do not hesitate. I loved my Nautilus (she's gone now unfortunately)

[sea-dweller]

I would not!

[j.alex]

Sure would


Sent from  iPad using Tapatalk

[Time Exposure]

Yes. Yes I would.
For one, I'm the only guy on the forum who doesn't appreciate GMT. Second of all, a Pro Series on a bracelet in gold is not comfortable for me. Third, I traded a 116509 WG Daytona for a "lowly" 5167 Aquanaut, in steel, on a rubber strap.
I'm as happy as can be.
Some don't like or don't "get" Patek Philippe. That's okay. I know some Omega guys who don't "get" Rolex.

[btinl]

I would make the trade. I'm currently on the hunt for a 5711

[Trouble15]

I wouldn't do it.

[ronburgundy]

I love that reference in YG, so, no, I wouldn't. Yeah I know, it's a Patek, but I have gold fever right now, plus that's one of the best looking references in YG in my opinion.

[Presa canary]

I would do the trade in a heartbeat

[Hairdude1]

I wouldn't

[BNA/LION]

Not me, I'd keep the Gold GMT C 116718.