PP 5167A vs. AP 15202

[jon_jon]

Both the 5167A and the 15202ST are great watches. You can't go wrong with either. My best advice is try them on at an AD first before you make your decision. If you can't find the SS versions of the 5167 or 15202, the ADs may have the RG versions to try on. The weight will be off, but you will get an idea how they look on the wrist.

[Tay821]

Originally Posted by jon_jon

Both the 5167A and the 15202ST are great watches. You can't go wrong with either. My best advice is try them on at an AD first before you make your decision. If you can't find the SS versions of the 5167 or 15202, the ADs may have the RG versions to try on. The weight will be off, but you will get an idea how they look on the wrist.

I've tried both. Tried on the 15202 while visiting NYC for the Patek exhibition and I was actually hoping I wouldn't like it to make my decision easier. Naturally the opposite happened. APs qc and service rep as well as the 5yr warranty helps me sleep a bit better a night vs the Patek, however the 5167 probably fits my lifestyle better right now with the rubber...

[Mitch105]

Love AP. But my choice is the 5167 especially if you actually found one available new from an AD.

[Abdullasaif]

15202 over the 5167 any day

[ap1]

5167 for a more carefree wearing experience

[NoVaSubowner]

5167 with a bracelet. Love mine. Better WR. Great accuracy and I think a better overall everyday watch.

In the 7 months I owned mine, it has been bulletproof. By comparison my 15400 had 2 trips to Clearwater due to mainspring issues. I