Trade It All In?

[Vipes]

DD40 platinum. More versatile due to the color. The heft, shine and brightness of the white metal makes it the ultimate Rolex, IMO.

[Brew]

As much as I might love the platinum piece, my (future) DD needs a fluted bezel, so yg for me, please.

[superdog]

Originally Posted by Rolex addict

You would be surprised at how comfortable platinum can be. It truly is amazing!!

not doubting it.

but they are heavy. and the president bracelet can be a challenge to get the fit right.

I would be more included to platona over the DD because of the ez link. But I would still choose the sub. Because anything that heavy, for me, would need to be pretty adjustable.

just my .02$

[dafuture]

DD or Sub, I always prefer white metals. White gold for me!

[Chiboy]

A few thoughts:

1) 20:1 watch trade. Wow! That's a record from my reading viewpoint. But I'd much rather have one great watch than (and I have no idea what OP is trading) 20 mediocre to pretty good watches. I would find that quite a simplifying relief

2) platinum as an everyday watch does not suck Having all your dough in one watch means you are enjoying your entire watch investment every day, rather than sitting 95% it of every day

3) I think a YG DD is a bit hard to pull off as your one and only, unless you are my father-in-law so I would seriously consider the lower profile white metals of WG or platinum

4) I love the WG sub, but really love the platinum DD you posted. If I were going 20:1, I'd want the one to be my all-time favorite, not a second choice (regardless of how nice), unless you plan on doing more of these expensive trade-ups

5) I might consider the WG/green dial DD mentioned earlier as a pretty cool, everyday wearable watch

6) Almost forgot: given bid/asked spreads, I would strongly consider selling some of your bigger value, easier to sell watches privately. Maybe generate better bucks on the easy stuff and trade in the less saleable stuff

Good luck!

[HogwldFLTR]

Originally Posted by Sarosh

Smurf.....

Lee, does this trade in also include your SkyD and newer 6 digit references? Or are there some from the current collection you will be holding on to???

It includes everything except a Hamilton Team Earth (a gift from work for being on the E R Team), my father's '60s Bulova, and my inherited gold Tiffany's pocket watch. Some how I also forgot about an older Zenith Pilot.

Originally Posted by asiparks

228206 from a TD runs low $40's....How does that compare to what your AD is asking ?
trading them to your AD might be the path of least resistance, it's also ( generally ), the path of least gain.

personally I dislike the Ice Blue dial, I'd go Everose with a chocolate dial or Wg/olive

Is your one watch solution for sure a Rolex?

This effort whether completed or not will give me a good feel for a base value for the collection. And re Rolex or other, yes I'm pretty much interested in the robustness and style of Rolex watches.

Originally Posted by Maiden

Hi, fascinating post, but we need to know, are you trading EVERYTHING in you own, or will some watches remain? This is critical to know before responding.

See above about family heirloom watches. None of what I'm retaining would work for me as a daily wearer.

Originally Posted by mjclark32

Jeez 3k for a djii

If you’re going down to one, the platinum dd40 is a damn stunner. Good luck!

It was that exact offer that taught me that the TS members aren't boy scouts and are absolutely willing to take advantage of members. Between that and the effort it takes to make photos to allay all the concerns, it's easier to just start with handing over a collection for evaluation and going from there.

Originally Posted by lhanddds

Curious also, You might consider going down to 2 or 3, unless you are seriously simplifying your life. Sounds exciting. I did something similar when I got my Big Red Daytona.i did not go down to one though.

I can make the decision once I have an offer. It's a starting point. I'm pretty certain there will be money left over at the end of the day.

Originally Posted by travisb

Wow! Quite the consolidation.
What sparked it?


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

What truly sparked it was my getting tired of trying to buy watches that aren't available and equally tired of having so many watches around. It just all started to feel very futile.

Originally Posted by superdog

Hi Lee,

Can you explain why you are doing this? That might help me to help determine what I would personally as a replacement.

The platinum DD is outrageous. However, I feel like that would be tough to have as an only. It is just so heavy and I personally can't imagine it would be comfortable full time.

I would likely go sub here as the bracelet will give you the most comfort and versatility.

However, I would still very much like to understand why.

And not that I don't agree. I agree whole heartedly actually. But I have my own reasons and I am curious what yours are.

See above for justification (perhaps a bad word). Additionally getting out of the game allows me some enjoyment and less frustration.

Originally Posted by superdog

not doubting it.

but they are heavy. and the president bracelet can be a challenge to get the fit right.

I would be more included to platona over the DD because of the ez link. But I would still choose the sub. Because anything that heavy, for me, would need to be pretty adjustable.

just my .02$

As much as I love the Daytona, as an engineer, it strikes me as excessive considering I've no real use for a chronograph as cool as they are. Watches with dates on them are sues all the time.

Originally Posted by Chiboy

A few thoughts:

1) 20:1 watch trade. Wow! That's a record from my reading viewpoint. But I'd much rather have one great watch than (and I have no idea what OP is trading) 20 mediocre to pretty good watches. I would find that quite a simplifying relief

2) platinum as an everyday watch does not suck Having all your dough in one watch means you are enjoying your entire watch investment every day, rather than sitting 95% it of every day

3) I think a YG DD is a bit hard to pull off as your one and only, unless you are my father-in-law so I would seriously consider the lower profile white metals of WG or platinum

4) I love the WG sub, but really love the platinum DD you posted. If I were going 20:1, I'd want the one to be my all-time favorite, not a second choice (regardless of how nice), unless you plan on doing more of these expensive trade-ups

5) I might consider the WG/green dial DD mentioned earlier as a pretty cool, everyday wearable watch

6) Almost forgot: given bid/asked spreads, I would strongly consider selling some of your bigger value, easier to sell watches privately. Maybe generate better bucks on the easy stuff and trade in the less saleable stuff

Good luck!

That is still definitely a potential.

I must admit that I had a nice time with my visit. Received a complimentary diet coke, and got to know the home store for Long's here in the Boston area. It was hard to tell a difference in weight between the Pt DD and Pt Daytona. I would hope to walk away with a check as well as a watch if that is the route that works out. Thanks for all the insightful questions and inputs!!!

[TripleB Boston]

Originally Posted by HogwldFLTR

I must admit that I had a nice time with my visit. Received a complimentary diet coke, and got to know the home store for Long's here in the Boston area. It was hard to tell a difference in weight between the Pt DD and Pt Daytona. I would hope to walk away with a check as well as a watch if that is the route that works out. Thanks for all the insightful questions and inputs!!!

Lee,
Did you talk with Mike at Long's? He's a nice guy. Very friendly and knowledgeable. I visited him when he was working in the Framingham store.
I always liked the Smurf or the blue face WG Pres.

Good luck!

[Sarosh]

Originally Posted by Chiboy

A few thoughts:

1) 20:1 watch trade. Wow! That's a record from my reading viewpoint. But I'd much rather have one great watch than (and I have no idea what OP is trading) 20 mediocre to pretty good watches. I would find that quite a simplifying relief

2) platinum as an everyday watch does not suck Having all your dough in one watch means you are enjoying your entire watch investment every day, rather than sitting 95% it of every day

3) I think a YG DD is a bit hard to pull off as your one and only, unless you are my father-in-law so I would seriously consider the lower profile white metals of WG or platinum

4) I love the WG sub, but really love the platinum DD you posted. If I were going 20:1, I'd want the one to be my all-time favorite, not a second choice (regardless of how nice), unless you plan on doing more of these expensive trade-ups

5) I might consider the WG/green dial DD mentioned earlier as a pretty cool, everyday wearable watch

6) Almost forgot: given bid/asked spreads, I would strongly consider selling some of your bigger value, easier to sell watches privately. Maybe generate better bucks on the easy stuff and trade in the less saleable stuff

Good luck!

Lee,

I agree with Chiboy having 1 solid watch to admire and use everyday is in my mind also the best option do you can give it all your attention and not feel bad about locking in so much investment in something you won’t wear everyday!

As much as I LOVE the WG Sub, love isn’t strong enough a word. For such a big consolidation 20-1 I would go PT.....enter Basel ‘19 Pt Sub/GMT. Sorted! Lol.

Whatever you decide I’m sure you’ll enjoy the thrill of the consolidation! Can’t wait to hear what you decide!

[Maiden]

HI Lee, as you will keep a few other special pieces, I would go for the PT DD all day long. I feel what you are feeling, I put a recent post up on this as well. Good luck and congrats. Keep us posted!

[Duey]

Originally Posted by HogwldFLTR

It was that exact offer that taught me that the TS members aren't boy scouts and are absolutely willing to take advantage of members. Between that and the effort it takes to make photos a ally all the concerns, it's easier to just start with handing over a collection for evaluation and going from there.

Totally agree on this one. I've had some eye opening offers too

[jsausley]

If I were super rich, a platinum DayDate with an ice blue dial would be in my collection.

I wouldn't get the white gold Sub because to me the Sub is a tool watch, and white gold is soft. I'd rather have the stainless.

[beshannon]

Originally Posted by HogwldFLTR

What truly sparked it was my getting tired of trying to buy watches that aren't available and equally tired of having so many watches around. It just all started to feel very futile.

Been there and still partially there. So much of the thrill is gone.

[HogwldFLTR]

Originally Posted by TripleB Boston

Lee,
Did you talk with Mike at Long's? He's a nice guy. Very friendly and knowledgeable. I visited him when he was working in the Framingham store.
I always liked the Smurf or the blue face WG Pres.

Good luck!

I was dealing with their Estate team (John and Rick) who handle purchasing watches as well as their sales guy Radwan. All were seemingly stand-up gents.

[sco]

You sold your 6 digit sub due to comfort issues, I only remember because you have mentioned it many times. Why would you think you would like the gold one more?

[Chiboy]

Originally Posted by HogwldFLTR

I was dealing with their Estate team (John and Rick) who handle purchasing watches as well as their sales guy Radwan. All were seemingly stand-up gents.

Everyone seems stand-up until you get their lowball, wholesale purchase offer.

[jinikari01]

I vote YG DD.
Simply bc its a grail watch me for.
This must be fun yet tough decision to make since you are only consider 1 watch from here on...

Cheers to whatever you decide to swap for and keep us posted on your final decision.

[Bigblu10]

Drastic move, but even I consolidated to one holy grail piece. I say go for a Day Date. Either in platinum, YG, RG or WG. Whichever color metal and dial combo which truly sings to you. Good luck whatever you decide!

[HogwldFLTR]

Originally Posted by sco

You sold your 6 digit sub due to comfort issues, I only remember because you have mentioned it many times. Why would you think you would like the gold one more?

Yes, that is definitely a consideration. I have time to look some more.

Originally Posted by Chiboy

Everyone seems stand-up until you get their lowball, wholesale purchase offer.

Absolutely. I'm certain which side their bread is buttered on. Without doubt!!! I had to come up with a number for the value of what I left at the shop. It was for insurance purposes and a back of the envelope type of number based on my replacement costs. I'll see what sort of fraction of that they offer.

[RX0]

are you trading your blue dial sky dweller?

Personally, I would not trade any Rolex watch for the blue dial sky dweller.

[dberman3]

Daydate. One of the most beautiful dials out there, in my opinion.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

[HogwldFLTR]

Originally Posted by RX0

are you trading your blue dial sky dweller?

Personally, I would not trade any Rolex watch for the blue dial sky dweller.

SkyD Blue, Daytona C Black, and SeaD C are all in the trade. The SeaD is my favorite of the three.

[droptopman]

Love that Plat DD with blue dial. Such a special watch. But I like Subs so would probably choose the WG LB Sub.

Just depends on your needs. Sport or sport/dress.

[tkerrmd]

Originally Posted by superdog

not doubting it.

but they are heavy. and the president bracelet can be a challenge to get the fit right.

I would be more included to platona over the DD because of the ez link. But I would still choose the sub. Because anything that heavy, for me, would need to be pretty adjustable.

just my .02$

This!

[VFA]

Sell everything privately and get the Pt DD. Be set for life.

[AK797]

Originally Posted by HogwldFLTR

SkyD Blue, Daytona C Black, and SeaD C are all in the trade. The SeaD is my favorite of the three.

I'd keep the D500 and sell the rest.

[R!$]

WG Sub

[Romeojk]

Hi Lee,
I’m fairly new to this so I’m not sure what to say about the dismantling of your years of collecting watches. One thing I am a bit familiar with is simplifying. And even though I watch and drool and dream over owning more, but am very content with the simplicity of just one watch. It stays on my wrist 24/7. It’s one less thing to worry about.

I hope you figure out what you want.

Submariner is my go to! I’m looking forward to seeing what you pick.

[BakerView]

Originally Posted by LuminousMaximus

Ok I would not trade to the AD. I would sell here on Trf. Fair price will sell fast.
Then you can keep half of your watches and still buy the WG Sub or the DD 40

You can tel it’s a 40 because the tag say 228238

I was thinking about selling mine as well and getting the Platinum DD batons
But I’m really digging the RG Daytona so... to be continued....

Are you adverse to selling them privately?

+1 ....and some of our good members will get a shot at your watch and the difference the AD would've gotten will be shared amongst friends instead.

[Nikrnic]

If l had the stones to pull off a big deal like your working on I'd go for the DD 228206 and never look back. Best of luck to you whatever you decide. Maybe we'll all see a big incoming soon.

Sent from my SM-G900V using Tapatalk

[MP5]

You could attractively price and sell your collection here and make a ton more than the AD will prolly offer, Seems that would be pretty cool and you might get a big trade offer for a gently used plat!