Funny how things grow on you...

[Tay821]

I thought the 5711 was the premier Nautilus but the more and more I see the 5712 the more I can't stop thinking about it. The shades of blue in different angles mixed with the red and MP get me more each time I see one. Some of the pics on Instagram are phenomenal. Those who has followed my posts know that I'm a huge 5167 fan, however I might have to make the 5712 my first Patek. I realize in the end I'll get both but know I won't be completely satisfied should I spring for the aqua first.

Arnaud, you're spot on buddy. You preach that it grows on you and couldn't be more right.

[rolex_addict]

5712 -> The ultimate nautilus

[Reky]

I can't agree more.

While 5711 is a very beautiful piece on its own, there are many more things to appreciate on the 5712, including the very useful power reserve and moonphase. The tinge of red on the 5712-1a gives it a nice contrast with the blue background, giving it a subtle yet sporty appeal.

Last but not least, the micro rotor movement is elegant and gorgeous....

[TimeOnHand]

I love them both

[sechsgang]

The 5711 (or 3700) will always be the classic Nautilus piece...but which one is "the greatest" is up for discussion at all times IMHO. Until they do a perpetual in the lineup anyways...

[codecow]

The 240 movement is also a nice feature of the 5712!

[mps354]

Love the micro rotor

[GB-man]

Best part about the 5712 is the movement followed by not having to look at the non matching date wheel.

[Vipes]

I can relate. I have a 5711 and I'm starting to fall for the 5712 for the same reasons that you mentioned. Also, you won't have to worry about the sticking date issue with the 5712.

[Charlie_pace]

Based solely on looks, 5711!

[goog53]

It is like picking between 2 supermodels. Cant go wrong with either one.

[AK797]

Love the 5712.

[Tay821]

Originally Posted by Vipes

I can relate. I have a 5711 and I'm starting to fall for the 5712 for the same reasons that you mentioned. Also, you won't have to worry about the sticking date issue with the 5712.

+1. I completely forgot that some experienced the sticking date issue. Heard that with the aqua as well.

[lapince]

Originally Posted by Tay821

I thought the 5711 was the premier Nautilus but the more and more I see the 5712 the more I can't stop thinking about it. The shades of blue in different angles mixed with the red and MP get me more each time I see one. Some of the pics on Instagram are phenomenal. Those who has followed my posts know that I'm a huge 5167 fan, however I might have to make the 5712 my first Patek. I realize in the end I'll get both but know I won't be completely satisfied should I spring for the aqua first.

Arnaud, you're spot on buddy. You preach that it grows on you and couldn't be more right.

Thanks buddy you can't be wrong with the 5712, I am going to Switzerland monday and will have my new 5712 on tuesday, of all the watches I saw and had it's by far the one I prefer, the 5711 is great but the 5712 is younger and more fun with the funky dial. The only pluses of the 5711 is the date window which is easier to read and the bigger WR, but I find the micro rotor, moon phase and power reserve very cool and interesting, the ideal is to have both of course, and a 5167, if possible the RG

[lapince]

Originally Posted by TimeOnHand

I love them both

Very cool Kevin

[Hollister]

Originally Posted by GB-man

Best part about the 5712 is the movement followed by not having to look at the non matching date wheel.

+1. I think the 5711 would look far better than it does if it had no date.

5712 is my favourite Naut by a long chalk. Awesome dial and movement.

[Tay821]

Stopped by the local AD today for a visit and he had a couple 5167s and a white 5711. I do like that white much more than I thought I would. You don't necessarily get the diff grey/blue at diff angles like the blue dial but something about the white tones that really pop out. Something I'd consider down the road definitely as I think there's always a place for white in a collection

[jon_jon]

Originally Posted by Tay821

Stopped by the local AD today for a visit and he had a couple 5167s and a white 5711. I do like that white much more than I thought I would. You don't necessarily get the diff grey/blue at diff angles like the blue dial but something about the white tones that really pop out. Something I'd consider down the road definitely as I think there's always a place for white in a collection

I think you should get the 5711 white dial, the 5712/1A and the 5167 I know it is tempting when it is right there available for you. I hope it won't be too long before you get to have all these pieces together in your collection. But as they say, patience is a virtue

[lapince]

Originally Posted by jon_jon

I think you should get the 5711 white dial, the 5712/1A and the 5167 I know it is tempting when it is right there available for you. I hope it won't be too long before you get to have all these pieces together in your collection. But as they say, patience is a virtue

The white dial is nice, but the blue is so much nicer IMO, I have already paid for a 5712 and a 5167R, will post an incoming for the Naut next week, and I am also on the list for a 5711 which should arrive in 2017, I think that will make an
awesome foursome with my AP ceramic diver, sure the 5711 and 5712 are very very alike, and so what, they are basically my two favorite SS watches, of course if ever for the 40th they introduce a blue dial Naut, for example a 5726, I could be tempted to get it instead of the 5711, anyways we will see, I much prefer the 5712 but as a daily the 5711 should be great with it's much more readable date, I sometimes had a hard time to read the date on the 5712

[willski]

Originally Posted by TimeOnHand

I love them both

Beautiful. Some days the 5711 looks nicer, others the 5712...

Your way is the best way :)


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Tay821]

Originally Posted by willski

Beautiful. Some days the 5711 looks nicer, others the 5712...

Your way is the best way :)


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

That's a great one of the 5712. Looks much more blue. I think the layout of the dial of the 5712 that screams Patek where the 5711 doesn't. Both are beautiful though. The bit of red and the moonphase is a game changer

[Tay821]

Originally Posted by jon_jon

I think you should get the 5711 white dial, the 5712/1A and the 5167 I know it is tempting when it is right there available for you. I hope it won't be too long before you get to have all these pieces together in your collection. But as they say, patience is a virtue

Patience is a virtue indeed. Luckily I'm not an impulse buyer. it was tempting not to buy either one today but I think I'm saving for the 5712 now. You're right though. All three WILL be in the collection eventually

[nilfire77]

5711 is more legible... 5712 is too busy looking for my liking...

[red1108nyc]

Originally Posted by vipes

i can relate. I have a 5711 and i'm starting to fall for the 5712 for the same reasons that you mentioned. Also, you won't have to worry about the sticking date issue with the 5712.

+1

[slashd0t]

I did the same thing... Wanted the 5711 and had zero interest in the chaotic dial of the 5712... However, curiosity got to me and I started researching the 5712 .... I now own a 5712..

[Hairdude1]

Originally Posted by TimeOnHand

I love them both

[rebel_1]

I've heard it said before, and I'll say it again. If part of a collection including Pateks, get the 5711. If not, get the 5712.