18038/18238 Links and Other Questions

[0xBA1EE7ED]

Good Morning!

It is looking like I might be picking up my first vintage soon and I have a few questions, I've done some searching but as always came away with more questions than answers.

As some back story, last year I was able to get my first Rolex, a 126710BLNR, new from an AD. I soon discovered that Rolexes have a higher nickel content than any other watch I have worn which has caused flare-ups of my nickel allergy. I tried to live with it through various means, but this has led me down the path of going PM which means vintage.

I am looking at 18038s and 18238s with the hopes of finding one at a reputable dealer with a similar value to my GMT so that I can trade it out directly; a 1987 or 1989 would be ideal. As this is my first vintage I am trying to go into this as prepared as possible.

Now, on to the questions.
First, I have a fairly large wrist and purchased an extra link for my GMT, most of the Day-Dates I have looked at seem to be sized quite small so I will need to purchase 1 if not 2 or 3 links to get the watch up to the correct size for me. I have seen links on eBay but haven't been able to find a dealer that has them listed, I want to be sure I am purchasing genuine parts; What would be the best way to ensure that if I end up buying on eBay or would going to a local AD be the best bet? Can ADs still get links for vintage watches?

Second, Bracelet stretch: How much is too much? Ultimately I'd love something factory tight and unworn but the value would be too high for a close trade with my watch. If I end up buying something thats a bit too stretched, is Rolliworks service the way to go?

Third, Dailying and Service: This would be my daily watch. I know that something in the late 80s/early 90s is still new enough to be dailyed without many issues; I would also most likely send it in for service after buying it unless it was explicitly stated that it had a recent service. Is there anything else I should be prepared for when dailying one of these or should I be prepared for a jaw dropping service cost?

And finally, avoiding fake parts/parts bin rebuilds/over-polished examples: I assume that all of the big dealers are going to be reputable and ensure everything is legitimate. But my knowledge of vintage rolexes isn't an ocean so much as a stream and when I am potentially in a shop looking at watches I won't have the experts here at hand. Is there anything I can look for directly to avoid buying something I shouldn't beyond buying the seller? Are there any dealers that are known to over-polish that I should avoid?

Thank you in advance for all answers and any links that will help! And of course, if anyone has any leads on watches/dealers where they think I might be able to do a direct trade or other words of wisdom, I am all ears!

[interestedwatcher]

With a 2023 126710BLNR I would be looking to trade into a really nice fullset 18238 (the double quickset is great) that is a full set with minimal wear. Or even a 118238 - this would likely take funds on top to get the 6 digit. If you find a model you like in good condition, you can have RSC service it an install a new dial (however I'd only do this if the dial on it is a standard champagne or similar, as you probably can't retain the original.)

Links can be bought from places such as overnightlinks, or at the AD. An AD will charge an obscene amount of money (likely 6 - 700 USD a link).

[0xBA1EE7ED]

Originally Posted by interestedwatcher

With a 2023 126710BLNR I would be looking to trade into a really nice fullset 18238 (the double quickset is great) that is a full set with minimal wear. Or even a 118238 - this would likely take funds on top to get the 6 digit. If you find a model you like in good condition, you can have RSC service it an install a new dial (however I'd only do this if the dial on it is a standard champagne or similar, as you probably can't retain the original.)

Links can be bought from places such as overnightlinks, or at the AD. An AD will charge an obscene amount of money (likely 6 - 700 USD a link).

That was my hope, being able to get into a nice fullset 18238, but it seems like values have dropped on the BLNR recently.
I did a trade/sell value with 2 of the larger dealers with the results being lower than expected. It looks like unless I sell my watch off privately (which I don't know if I am experienced enough to do) I would have to add a bit to get into a nice 18238.
I did look at a very nicely, nearly unworn 18238 but it involved me adding around $4,000. And it was definitely one I'd want to send in for service with how little it was used just to make sure everything is running well.

I do appreciate the shoutout for overnightlinks, didn't know about them!

I will keep looking around and seeing what I can find for a good trade.

[wilsonpepper]

" nearly unworn 18238 but it involved me adding around $4,000"

What was the price of the 18238 ??

[Phrank]

A couple of months ago I might have been interested in that trade.

I had my 18238 Ivory/Silver dial serviced in 2019, it's an A-Serial, so 1999, last of the 5 digits, in superb shape. Bracelet is perfect, no stretch at all. When I purchased it, full set, it had been a safe queen, green sticker still on the back intact, Rolex Tech said case had never been opened when I took it in for its service. My wrist is 7.5 and could move the bracelet probably enough that it might have fit you without any extra links.

But fell in love with the 5 digit Rolex GMT Pepsi 16700 and found one that fit the bill.

The Day-Date is a tank of a watch, don't wear it as much as I'd like, have thought of moving it on a few times, but my son loves it.....

Good luck in your hunt, definitely try to get as late 90's as you can and as you note, make sure the bracelet is in great shape and the dial is perfect.

Here's a pic of my 1999 A-Serial 18238 Rolex Day-Date.

[fivedime]

Bracelet stretch: the intake guidance sheet Rolex provides shows bracelet sag making a full “U” as the guideline for *requiring* replacement. Anything less than that is up to the wearer’s tolerance as to how much is “too much.”

[0xBA1EE7ED]

Originally Posted by wilsonpepper

" nearly unworn 18238 but it involved me adding around $4,000"

What was the price of the 18238 ??

$18.6k, from that you can infer how much I was being offered.

Originally Posted by Phrank

A couple of months ago I might have been interested in that trade.

I had my 18238 Ivory/Silver dial serviced in 2019, it's an A-Serial, so 1999, last of the 5 digits, in superb shape. Bracelet is perfect, no stretch at all. When I purchased it, full set, it had been a safe queen, green sticker still on the back intact, Rolex Tech said case had never been opened when I took it in for its service. My wrist is 7.5 and could move the bracelet probably enough that it might have fit you without any extra links.

But fell in love with the 5 digit Rolex GMT Pepsi 16700 and found one that fit the bill.

The Day-Date is a tank of a watch, don't wear it as much as I'd like, have thought of moving it on a few times, but my son loves it.....

Good luck in your hunt, definitely try to get as late 90's as you can and as you note, make sure the bracelet is in great shape and the dial is perfect.

Here's a pic of my 1999 A-Serial 18238 Rolex Day-Date.

That is a beautiful example! Thank you for the encouragement, I am currently looking at a few with 1 being more early 90s but am keeping my eyes out constantly.

[southtexas]

Links pop up pretty regularly for sale here in the parts/accessories section (and they'll be much cheaper than buying new from AD). Do your homework even buying from sellers here on the forum.

[0xBA1EE7ED]

Am I allowed to post photos of watches I am looking at here for opinions?

[ronricks]

Originally Posted by 0xBA1EE7ED

Am I allowed to post photos of watches I am looking at here for opinions?

Absolutely

[Phrank]

Originally Posted by 0xBA1EE7ED

Am I allowed to post photos of watches I am looking at here for opinions?

Absolutely, this forum has been incredible helping me and many others make the best decision regarding potential purchases.

It's easy to get emotionally attached to a watch you find, and the forum removes the film of excitement from your eyes and provides an objective view. Let alone when the actual reference experts check in....

Just be patient, keep an open mind, and take your time finding the right example of the watch you want - it's going to be with you for a long time.

Good Luck and Good Hunting!

[0xBA1EE7ED]

I will make these separate posts within the thread so I can't confuse them.

This first one I've already shown to Phrank who advised me that the dial has a blemish which isn't good. And we have no photos of the clasp to determine if its original. But other than that it looks good.

Pro-CaptureOne003415copy.jpg

Pro-CaptureOne02884copy.jpg

Pro-CaptureOne00528.jpg

$16k

[0xBA1EE7ED]

This one is from Tropical, who I know is respected here.

Again, no photos of the clasp but he says it matches. This is only a single quickset however.

b4312a3877cb2534b015faf7faf9e920bc25a2762f2332bb5460cae1c61b4547.jpeg

b4312a3877cb2534b015faf7faf9e920bc25a2762f2332bb5460cae1c61b4547 (1).jpeg

b4312a3877cb2534b015faf7faf9e920bc25a2762f2332bb5460cae1c61b4547 (2).jpeg

b4312a3877cb2534b015faf7faf9e920bc25a2762f2332bb5460cae1c61b4547 (3).jpeg

$17,350

[0xBA1EE7ED]

This one is a double quickset. Fullset and unpolished. Looks to be in really good condition from my eyes but I have not heard much about this dealer and it may be out of my trade-price range.

IMG_9474_1200x.jpeg

IMG_9477_3256a062-4320-4e98-897f-79a3cc4b7a49_1200x.jpg

IMG_9479_f27021c9-f6d9-495d-8299-375a880d7497_1200x.jpg

IMG_9470_bd8387a8-5e0d-4536-8e41-c7b860f2be62_1200x.jpg

$20,495

[Phrank]

Originally Posted by 0xBA1EE7ED

This one is from Tropical, who I know is respected here.

Again, no photos of the clasp but he says it matches. This is only a single quickset however.

Attachment 1443186

Love the open 6 on this one....

Might help to add prices.

[0xBA1EE7ED]

Originally Posted by Phrank

Love the open 6 on this one....

Might help to add prices.

I like the Open 6 too, and I am not opposed to single. I added prices.

Basically $16k, $17k, $20k in that order.

[0xBA1EE7ED]

Heres another 18038 from a trusted seller here. This one is $15,250. No mention of polishing, clasp is correctly coded.

7G6A1117.jpg

7G6A1142.jpg

7G6A1149.jpg

7G6A1147.jpg

[hutch300]

I saw that one from Jacek today aka tropicalwatch. Great seller and I like that combo.

[miamiclay]

I expect I would be happy with either of the first two.

If the dial blemish you refer to is the one at :18 on the first watch, I don’t know if it would be visible to the naked eye, and it’s a really handsome and uncommon disc marker dial.

Broadly though, I think a white dial looks better than champagne on these.

[0xBA1EE7ED]

How does this one look for $17k? It does have an engraving on the caseback but I am ok with it.

IMG_7546_5c680a7f-570d-4132-9e1b-d7ce69ad17c6_1100x copy.jpg

IMG_7602_2200x copy.jpg

IMG_7640_1ba8eda5-81b1-47f0-80f9-a0d2ee47f7aa_2200x copy.jpg