Trading for One Size Bigger

[gabbs1123]

Has anyone traded their watch for the same exact configuration but just the next size up? Just curious about this. Thanks!

[Kevin of Larchmont]

The opposite, I traded down from a DJII to a DJ36. I realize that doesn’t answer your question though.

[gabbs1123]

Originally Posted by Kevin of Larchmont

The opposite, I traded down from a DJII to a DJ36. I realize that doesn’t answer your question though.

I am thinking of potentially going from 31 to 36.

[Kevin of Larchmont]

I went from a 34 (Oyster Date) to a 42 (DJII) to a 36 (DJ and Explorer). 36mm remains a sweet spot among my other larger watches.

[Bazil]

No … 40mm for me is perfect .. I’ll stay there ..

[mikea]

I'm considering going the other way. Moving my WG YM 42 for a RG YM 40

[Kenny G]

If you love the watch but feel it’s too small and that you should have gone with the larger dial do it…I wouldn’t worry who else has done it before.

[996marty]

Originally Posted by gabbs1123

I am thinking of potentially going from 31 to 36.

I haven’t personally done the switch but my wife has and she went from a 26 to a 40. And her new watch doesn’t look out of place.

[Daytonaman799]

Originally Posted by gabbs1123

Has anyone traded their watch for the same exact configuration but just the next size up? Just curious about this. Thanks!

Went from DD 36 to DD 40 in platinum.

[brandrea]

I tried watches in a variety of sizes from 36 to 44mm. 40mm (ish) Rolex seem to suit me best.

[travisb]

I haven't. Usually, anything in the professional line suits my taste.

[1William]

I have.

[gabbs1123]

Originally Posted by Daytonaman799

Went from DD 36 to DD 40 in platinum.

How long after the purchase of the first watch did you do this? Also, did you do this with an AD or Gray?

[Rocky Hockey]

I went from a 36MM to 39MM Explorer I. My wife wears a 36MM Datejust which I think looks great on her smaller wrists. My wrists are pretty small at about 6.70 inches. I also have a 36MM Datejust but am considering going to 41MM.


No wrong decision in my opinion. Life is short.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[KathleenL]

Gabbs, the photo you posted (in a different thread) after you bought your DJ 31mm was stunning. The watch looked perfect on your wrist. My vote would be for you to stick with the 31mm.

I wear a 28mm Lady Datejust. It’s a two-tone Everose with a Sundust dial. Before I got it, I had worn a 27mm Tag Heuer for many, many years, so when Hubs said he wanted to buy me the Rolex, I didn’t even think about a size other than the 28mm. I suppose a 31mm would look fine on my wrist, but my wrist right now is barely over 6” so I think what I have is perfect. My wrist was about 6.5” when I got the Rolex almost 2.5 years ago, but I’ve lost weight (and am still losing), so going to a larger watch isn’t on my radar. I want to wear the watch, I don’t want the watch to wear me, if you know what I mean. I don’t want to flash “look at my Rolex!”

[Daytona king]

Originally Posted by Daytonaman799

Went from DD 36 to DD 40 in platinum.

Love the 40. Looks perfect on you.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[spellmanski]

I'd like to go the other way - from my DJ41 to DJ36!

[RichM]

Yes 34mm OP to a 40mm Sub.

[Mate1974]

Funny you ask, because I actually went through this exact situation! I had a 36mm Rolex Datejust that I absolutely loved, but over time I started feeling like I wanted something with a bit more wrist presence. I was torn because the configuration—blue dial, fluted bezel, Jubilee bracelet—was perfect, and I didn’t want to lose that.

After a lot of back and forth, I found an AD willing to work with me on trading my 36mm for the 41mm version in the exact same configuration. When I finally got the larger size, it felt like I was still wearing the same watch I loved, but with that extra oomph I was looking for. It was honestly the best of both worlds. So, if you’re feeling like the next size up is calling your name, it might be worth the switch! Just make sure you try it on to be sure it gives you that perfect fit.

[gabbs1123]

Originally Posted by Mate1974

Funny you ask, because I actually went through this exact situation! I had a 36mm Rolex Datejust that I absolutely loved, but over time I started feeling like I wanted something with a bit more wrist presence. I was torn because the configuration—blue dial, fluted bezel, Jubilee bracelet—was perfect, and I didn’t want to lose that.

After a lot of back and forth, I found an AD willing to work with me on trading my 36mm for the 41mm version in the exact same configuration. When I finally got the larger size, it felt like I was still wearing the same watch I loved, but with that extra oomph I was looking for. It was honestly the best of both worlds. So, if you’re feeling like the next size up is calling your name, it might be worth the switch! Just make sure you try it on to be sure it gives you that perfect fit.

How did you get an AD to do this? I was thinking only way to do it would be to go gray.

[Guppydriver]

Originally Posted by mikea

I'm considering going the other way. Moving my WG YM 42 for a RG YM 40

Because of the size or the color of gold primarily? I only ask because RG is not available in 42 IIRC.

[Guppydriver]

Technically the OP is asking if anyone has downsized a watch of the exact configuration. Meaning, let’s say… a large silver dial OP down to a 36mm or a 41mm DJ with fluted bezel, sticks, and black dial on jubilee for exactly the same color and configuration but in 36mm.

I’m sure there are quite a few, but I would find it a little less satisfying to “use an allocation” on an a smaller identical reference. I’d want it to feel more like a “new to me” watch by having at least something different.

[KathleenL]

Originally Posted by Guppydriver

Technically the OP is asking if anyone has downsized a watch of the exact configuration. Meaning, let’s say… a large silver dial OP down to a 36mm or a 41mm DJ with fluted bezel, sticks, and black dial on jubilee for exactly the same color and configuration but in 36mm.

I’m sure there are quite a few, but I would find it a little less satisfying to “use an allocation” on an a smaller identical reference. I’d want it to feel more like a “new to me” watch by having at least something different.

Actually, the OP is asking if anyone has upsized a watch of the exact same configuration. She is contemplating replacing her 31 mm DJ with a 36 mm DJ of the exact same configuration.

[Guppydriver]

Originally Posted by KathleenL

Actually, the OP is asking if anyone has upsized a watch of the exact same configuration. She is contemplating replacing her 31 mm DJ with a 36 mm DJ of the exact same configuration.

Oops…

I would have been right on Opposite Day!

[SudiYunus]

Originally Posted by KathleenL

Actually, the OP is asking if anyone has upsized a watch of the exact same configuration. She is contemplating replacing her 31 mm DJ with a 36 mm DJ of the exact same configuration.

[JSCP]

A few years ago I traded a DD 36 yg for a DD40 yg

i
liked the classic 36 , but love the weight of hold on DD40, so then hod it RG and WG!

[gabbs1123]

Originally Posted by KathleenL

Actually, the OP is asking if anyone has upsized a watch of the exact same configuration. She is contemplating replacing her 31 mm DJ with a 36 mm DJ of the exact same configuration.

Yes, that’s what I meant 😀

[MichelleP]

When I 1st started buying nice watches I went with Tag 28mm. I quickly realized that was too small. I now wear anywhere from 36-42mm. I find a lot of women strart out small and realize 36mm is the way to go.