Tudor Black Bay Blue 58 - The hands don't match the dial (New Watch), Bad QC?

[JR16]

The watch looks totally normal to me in the last set of photos


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

[steveclr]

Yes, that last photo set makes everything look like it matches much better. I'd have no problem with the watch as it appears in the initial post, but if it bothers you, try to get it corrected of course.

[inadeje]

I would return this watch without hesitation. There’s no way that you can unsee that, plus it will give the watch a dubious resale value if you decide at some point to trade or sell.

[shaunylw]

My hands matches the plots on my 58.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[GGGMT]

Originally Posted by ryansoulsit

I purchased the watch from the AD.

I went back to the AD today and they have another watch for comparison (same model, brand new, I can switch to it if I want). But they just look identical, so I decided the keep the watch.

Interestingly, when I wanted a black Bay 58 ag, I went to my AD and tried one on, and the hands were mismatch just like yours. AD acknowledged the mismatch, but told me that nine out of 10 buyers wouldn’t care. I told them to call me when they got the next one in, and I went there again, and the hands on that one were mismatched just like yours. I told them to call me when they got the next one in, and I went there a 3d time, and the hands matched. And I bought it. And I absolutely love it




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[dlrolex]

Disturbing

[vipereaper30]

Interesting, I have four BB58s and none of them have a mismatch on the hands or plots. It looks a little off from your initial photos although your second set looks just fine. Does it bother you?

[Iowa_Watchman]

I have a blue 58 that was purchased new in March 2022 and I am experiencing the same issue. I purchased the watch from the original owner and I noticed it almost immediately when I took it out of the box. I think it’s hard to pick up in pictures, but much more noticeable in person. I’m probably going to contact RSC this week and see if it’s something they’d be willing to take care of.