SD43 for Kermit

[ciandro]

Fell in love with a Kermit I saw in a store. Full set, 2005 Rolex 16610LV "Kermit" with box papers booklets and even the little anchor accessory. Never polished. Impeccable bezel insert, all extensions and links, single owner.

Deal: I could get Kermit by trading my 2021 SD43 + $2,000.

Thoughts?

[NCD1979]

Personally, I’d stick with the SD. Updated movement, ceramic bezel….just more watch for the $ IMHO. That being said, go with what you like.

[ciandro]

Originally Posted by NCD1979

Personally, I’d stick with the SD. Updated movement, ceramic bezel….just more watch for the $ IMHO. That being said, go with what you like.

True. I do have all the above things in my 2021 126610LN Sub. The SD43 is starting to feel quite heavy and the Kermit's size was refreshing.

[ttomczak]

If you fell in love with it, and that’s what you really really want… Do it, it’s not about the cost.

If it’s only for speculation, I wouldn’t because then you won’t have one to actually wear.

[Mal H.]

As a bona-fide 5-digit fan I say 5-digit all the things. I like the SD43, but it's no Kermit.

[101031-28]

Since you have the 126LN and the SD43 is starting to feel heavy on your wrist, I would do it. Provided you absolutely love the 16610LV

[Driver8]

As someone who's owned a 16610LV, and currently owns an SD43 (although, not for much longer), I'd say buy the LV.

The ceramic bezel is great on the SD43, but the latest movement may cause you problems (like mine has), plus the LV is just a stone-cold classic.

[ciandro]

Originally Posted by Mal H.

As a bona-fide 5-digit fan I say 5-digit all the things. I like the SD43, but it's no Kermit.

I used to be a 5 digit only collector and recently switched to the new line and collection for the improved features/movement/ceramic/etc...

Yes, considering i do get the tech from my new sub, I do miss the vibe of the neo-vintage stuff... and that green is just "oh-my!"

[Mifune]

no thank you... keep your station.

[Mal H.]

Originally Posted by ciandro

I used to be a 5 digit only collector and recently switched to the new line and collection for the improved features/movement/ceramic/etc...

Yes, considering i do get the tech from my new sub, I do miss the vibe of the neo-vintage stuff... and that green is just "oh-my!"

Yep. I think the LV is a better compliment to the 12LN than the SD43. IMO the 12LN and SD43 are just two different sizes of the same watch.

[Emerald4194]

If you already have a 6 digit sub, and teh SD is not as comfortable as the Kermit, I wold definitely get the OG Kermit

[got369]

IMO. For wearability the Kermit

IMO.For collectability the Kermit. It’s already a collectible.

I would chose the Kermit.

[Master_Grogu]

Don’t “upgrade” backward.

You’re paying a big premium just for some green pigments.

[watchwatcher]

Originally Posted by ciandro

Fell in love with a Kermit I saw in a store. Full set, 2005 Rolex 16610LV "Kermit" with box papers booklets and even the little anchor accessory. Never polished. Impeccable bezel insert, all extensions and links, single owner.

Deal: I could get Kermit by trading my 2021 SD43 + $2,000.

Thoughts?

Nope. Trade your sub and pay whatever, but not the SD. My two cents.

[herts9]

I'd trade straight up, and even I would have a hard time doing that. I'm a SD43 fan, and there's always been something that put me off with the Kermit shade of green.

To wear, keep the SD43.
To stash away, go for the LV.

[FTX I]

Originally Posted by ciandro

Full set, 2005 Rolex 16610LV "Kermit" with box papers booklets and even the little anchor accessory. Never polished. Impeccable bezel insert, all extensions and links, single owner.

Originally Posted by 101031-28

Since you have the 126LN and the SD43 is starting to feel heavy on your wrist, I would do it.

Originally Posted by Emerald4194

If you already have a 6 digit sub, and the SD is not as comfortable as the Kermit, I wold definitely get the OG Kermit

Originally Posted by Driver8

the latest movement may cause you problems (like mine has), plus the LV is just a stone-cold classic.

I think opportunities play a big part on this hobby, so considering the reasons above I'd say go ahead and do it as soon as you can.

[MONTANTK]

I would do that. The Kermit is a really nice looking watch and one that I admire whenever I see it

[brandrea]

This thread really does require a picture

[crazycarlitos]

If u say “I fell in love”… the decision is already made, I m sure. Lol
U r just looking for validation.

Go for it.
The deal is not great.. but not too bad.

Personally, I would add the 16610LV.. and join the 50/50 club

But if u find the sd43 uncomfy, u might as well trade it for something u love.

*thread needs pics. lol

[crazycarlitos]

Originally Posted by brandrea

This thread really does require a picture

Haha was thinking same

[brandrea]

Originally Posted by crazycarlitos

If u say “I fell in love”… the decision is already made, I m sure. Lol
U r just looking for validation.

Go for it.
The deal is not great.. but not too bad.

Personally, I would add the 16610LV.. and join the 50/50 club

But if u find the sd43 uncomfy, u might as well trade it for something u love.

*thread needs pics. lol

Sent from my SM-G960W using Tapatalk

[Seddyspaghetti]

Matter of preference imo. One can be perceived as “old and dated” and the other as “too big” practically speaking.

Really up to you. I’m not crazy about either but if i had to choose, the LV.

[mike morris]

do it !

[KyloRen]

Kermit is totally worth it. But id do SD43 +1K instead.

[jaySL350]

Love the Kermit,,,
Saw nos.late 5 digit Kermit over here a few months back,,,around £17+

[ciandro]

Here is a photo!




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[zoenatenich]

I would not do the trade. I will save and add the Kermit to my collection instead.

[dannyp]

Originally Posted by ciandro

True. I do have all the above things in my 2021 126610LN Sub. The SD43 is starting to feel quite heavy and the Kermit's size was refreshing.

These are two crucial pieces of information that suggest you'd be happiest trading the SD43. The question is: Do you trade it towards a Kermit, or something else?

I understand the collectibility of the LN, but just find that color green aesthetically unpleasing, to be honest. If I were trading for a five-digit, I'd look for the most impeccable 14060, as it is truly the original.

Now, all of that said, I might also be on the lookout for a mint (even unworn) SD4k. Has many of your Sub's features without the SD43's size. However I would anticipate putting up a minimum of $5,000 additional for a BNIB version (based on C24...).

[emtee]

100% yes. I would assume the Kermit would require more cash. I have a BLNR and would be interested in trading it for a Kermit. Always assumed they’d appreciated loads.

[ciandro]

Would you say, from a value perspective, this being a 2005 and not having the ROLEX rehaut it would make it "closer" to the original anniversary mode?