Two-Watch Collection: Keep the Speedy or Swap for a Datejust?

[sls70]

Currently, I have a 126610LV Mk2 and a Speedmaster 3861 Sapphire. I want to stick to a two-watch collection. The Sub is definitely staying.

Lately, I’ve been considering a Datejust 36 (fluted bezel, Jubilee, blue dial). Ideally, I’d keep all three, but that’s not an option right now. While I really like the Speedy, I can’t help but feel it’s not quite on the same level as a Rolex.

Would you keep the Speedy, or swap it for the Datejust? Any thoughts?

[rmlovett1]

I’d personally swap…but it’d be a DJ41 for me.

[brandrea]

Well you know what I’m gonna say … The Speedy stays

[Zorro79]

I would keep the speedmaster. It’s a great two watch collection. I’d probably contact Aaron at Aaron bespoke and buy a ton of colorful and exotic straps and keep the speedmaster on leather - for varieties sake.

[OG1982]

I sold my 3861 after 6 months. It's a nice Chrono and has a vastly superior bracelet to most Omegas within its price point. But it isn't half a boring watch.

[1William]

I would keep the 3861. Buy some straps, have some fun.

[Marcjvr]

Easy decision, keep the speedy.

[Rolexken]

Originally Posted by rmlovett1

I’d personally swap…but it’d be a DJ41 for me.

This.

[metallic]

Not a big fan of the Speedy but I would keep it over a DJ 36. DJ 41 I would swap.

[JRell]

I would for a BLNR on jubilee. You mentioned swapping them. How much are you expecting to get from the speedmaster? You are going to have to add a good amount of cash for the datejust.

[Calatrava r]

Since you have the Omega, I would keep it and not trade it for any DJ.

[swils8610]

Make the switch


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro

[Barada7]

I’m contemplating something similar. If the DJ41 in blue is offered, my white dial 3861 will likely be on the move.

[Harry-57]

I'd keep the Speedy. Sounds like you want to.

[m j b]

The Speedy is a strap monster. Swap those around and it will look and feel like a new watch any time you get bored.

[JRell]

Can you add the OP 41 blue dial and keep the speedmaster?

[Bazil]

Speedy stays, gives you that bit of variety …

[lord91]

I say trade it for that DJ.

[BraveBold]

Have both. I would wait until you can just add the DJ… that said, I buy my watches to keep and not the type to trade in / out of stuff…


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[watchwatcher]

Originally Posted by sls70

Ideally, I’d keep all three, but that’s not an option right now.

In these type situations, I've found it best not to make a move.

[sportsfan0704]

Have had all 3 watches. I’d get the datejust now and reaquire the speedy later.

[Yobber76]

I'd probably swap the Speedy for the DJ. I'm in the dress watch state of mind at this point of my life. Plus I like a date complication.

[Mystro]

The Omega is worth more than what you can trade it in for.

[padi56]

Originally Posted by brandrea

Well you know what I’m gonna say … The Speedy stays

Have to agree would keep the speedy over any DJ.

[77T]

Originally Posted by sls70

Ideally, I’d keep all three, but that’s not an option right now. While I really like the Speedy, I can’t help but feel it’s not quite on the same level as a Rolex.

But the Speedy is a level above a pedestrian DJ.

Don't let branding affect judgment.

Give this desire for a DJ some time. Since you can't afford it as a standalone purchase right now, by waiting you'll surely find a way to get it down the road if the desire sticks with you.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[gamingdoctor]

I'd make your 2 watch collection a 3 watch collection.

[123Blueface]

Originally Posted by rmlovett1

it’d be a DJ41 for me.

Exactly, although the Speedmaster is in a league of its own compared to a DJ.

[~JJ]

Is the amount of return for speedy really worth it? Seems better to add when the timing is right.

[Flipmarine2k]

Though decision, if you can keep the speedy and add the DJ that would be most ideal 3 watch collection. 3 of the most iconic pieces in history

[WatchGuy1966]

Keep the Speedmaster