5130p vs. 5146p

[jon_jon]

Originally Posted by nyc2la

Thanks everyone. I already have a PC and a PCC, so the WT seems like a more logical addition, but I do like both. I'm also a bigger fan of blue, so that also is influencing my decision.

I think it depends on if you like variety in your collection or enjoy similar watches.

Some people like the Nautilus series and will primarily focus on that collection. Others will collect chronographs and perpetual chronographs, because they have traditionally done well at watch auctions.

I personally like variety as long as it is a watch I will wear. But it depends on your personal taste as a collector.

[lapince]

Originally Posted by Flex368

Looking at the PPs you already own I´d skip both references.

If I had to buy one I´d go for the 5146P.

which does he own?

[Flex368]

5270 and 5140, have a look at his profile.

[cinch]

Also the 5711 I think

[nyc2la]

Originally Posted by Flex368

5270 and 5140, have a look at his profile.

Originally Posted by cinch

Also the 5711 I think

Hi Gents,

Yup, those are my 3 Pateks.

[ap1]

5146 but id pass on these given some of your beauties

[dom007]

Originally Posted by nyc2la

Hi Gents,

Yup, those are my 3 Pateks.

Now, you need defenitely something in black! If needed I am willing to give a recommendation...

[nyc2la]

Originally Posted by dom007

Now, you need defenitely something in black! If needed I am willing to give a recommendation...

And a loan???

[archer75]

I like to wt complication but I would not buy it as half of the year it does not show the correct time.

[dom007]

[KarlS]

Originally Posted by archer75

I like to wt complication but I would not buy it as half of the year it does not show the correct time.

No it shows the correct time wherever you are but it would not accurately display the time in those cities that use daylight saving

[Oryx]

5130P hands down for me

[archer75]

Originally Posted by KarlS

No it shows the correct time wherever you are but it would not accurately display the time in those cities that use daylight saving

Yes, that is exactly what I tried to mean. When this is the case, I can not convincing myself to hv it. There is something I do not understand perhaps as top brands PP, VC, ALS all have the same at their worldtimers. I believe this is against the idea of such complication.

[Finkalot]

If you have a 5270 and 5140 already, then skip both these references. I love the 5146 so this is a lot coming from me. If I were in your position, I'd go for an ALS datograph up down. Sorry for this on a PP forum but that's what I would do.




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[KarlS]

Originally Posted by Finkalot

If you have a 5270 and 5140 already, then skip both these references. I love the 5146 so this is a lot coming from me. If I were in your position, I'd go for an ALS datograph up down. Sorry for this on a PP forum but that's what I would do.




Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

The guy has a 5270 and you suggest a Datograph!! That doesn't make sense! The 5146 doesn't make sense has he has a PC! WT are fun and a complication absent in the collection so it's a slam dunk!

[Finkalot]

Originally Posted by KarlS

The guy has a 5270 and you suggest a Datograph!! That doesn't make sense! The 5146 doesn't make sense has he has a PC! WT are fun and a complication absent in the collection so it's a slam dunk!

Yeah perhaps. I've never been into WTs really so that might be driving my recommendation.

The datograph is (in my opinion) one of the few watches for which you'd go outside the Patek family. Platinum and dark dial option available :)

That's what I would do if I was already the owner of a 5270!


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk