Hulk vs CHNR Root Beer

[interestedinwatches]

Downsizing my collection and these are too similar to keep both. Which would you choose to keep?

[Bxtek]

Those are 2 of my favorite models. I would have a real tough time letting go of either tbh. IMO, they are two very different watches. Both are obviously sports watches, but one is full SS, green dial/bezel, no GMT. The other is a TT, no green in the dial or bezel, GMT complication. They are not similar looking at all imo.

I guess if I HAD to let one go, it would be the Hulk by a very small margin. The Root Beer is more versatile and can be for casual and full formal use. I also like the GMT complication.

[Presa canary]

I agree, much to similar. Please send them to me for a thorough once over to make an educated decision

[Subguy48]

Hulk is more iconic and harder to repurchase down the road.

[SS Oyster]

Hulk by a mile!







Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[Little machines]

Both are great looking watches ! I would keep the hulk!

[interestedinwatches]

I am personally leaning towards the CHNR to keep. I have a baguette platinum Daytona, and I feel like it does what the Hulk does but better. CHNR has qualities that the 116506 doesn't have however... Just where I personally stand at the moment

[Cru Jones]

As much as I like the CHNR, if only one, it would be the 116610LV.

[JPS]

Originally Posted by interestedinwatches

I am personally leaning towards the CHNR to keep. I have a baguette platinum Daytona, and I feel like it does what the Hulk does but better. CHNR has qualities that the 116506 doesn't have however... Just where I personally stand at the moment

I’ve got them both & between the 2 I would keep the Rootbeer. My reasons being I find it a classier & more versatile watch compared to the Hulk which i find to be a spectacular one trick pony.

[Sweetswisssteel]

Hulk. I love the full gold rooty but not keen on the TT.

Sent from my Pixel 6 Pro using Tapatalk

[travisb]

LV stays.

[enjoythemusic]

Needs an option for BOTH. :)

[brandrea]

LVC for me. Diver would be the last to go for me

[rmlovett1]

Definitely not too similar IMO, but my opinion doesn’t count.
My choice would be the hulk more than likely, but it would also depend on what I would have left in the collection.

[Harry-57]

They are not similar in complications. The GMT is more useful to me. Having said that, there is no way my Hulk is going anywhere.

[Jonny8]

I’d keep both if I could. If forced to choose I’d probably keep the ‘Hulk’ as it is discontinued and so harder to replace if you get sellers remorse.

Other than that I love both of these references.

[Tensai]

Green green.

[FrankNYC]

Originally Posted by interestedinwatches

Downsizing my collection and these are too similar to keep both. Which would you choose to keep?

Too similar? people here (myself included) have 2-3 Submariners; one with date, one without, or one 5 digit ref the other a 6 digit ref since they're "different"

Anyway, between the two I'd keep the CHNR.

[JRell]

Originally Posted by franknyc

too similar? People here (myself included) have 2-3 submariners; one with date, one without, or one 5 digit ref the other a 6 digit ref since they're "different"

Anyway, between the two i'd keep the chnr.

+1

[vesnyder]

I’ve got them both & between the 2 I would keep the Rootbeer. My reasons being I find it a classier & more versatile watch compared to the Hulk which i find to be a spectacular one trick pony.

Have to agree, but I am an owner of the CHNR so I may be a bit biased, but I do alos agree that the Hulk is harder to purchase.

[joli160]

I believe that the LV is a bit overhyped, they could not give them away before and all of a sudden they took off.
Never liked the mismatch between bezel and dial.

It’s an easy sell so let it go and keep the most beautiful GMT

[RDT-G23]

Green.

[KeithP]

Originally Posted by joli160

I believe that the LV is a bit overhyped, they could not give them away before and all of a sudden they took off.
Never liked the mismatch between bezel and dial.

It’s an easy sell so let it go and keep the most beautiful GMT

Have to agree w this. Wouldn’t mind a green sub myself, but…

[Me4u2night]

How are these similar? Because they tell time?

[fishingbear]

Keep the LV Sub.

[1William]

I would keep the Hulk. Discontinued model that can not as easily be replaced going forward. The Root Beer, cool watch but still in production.

[JRell]

I went root beer here because I don’t like the green dial in the sunlight, too bright neon light green. I had the root beer, but didn’t love the brown. Love my 12LV.

[Bazil]

My choice would be to keep the Hulk ..

[ltmgeller]

Keep the hulk

[Kiddodoc]

I think many have a love-hate relationship with the Hulk. On one hand I loved looking at the dial with white lettering. It is so unique for Rolex's history and is truly one of a king and can be a daily for many. On the other hand, the green dial in direct sunlight was just waaaay tooo damn green and I am not crazy about the super case but some love it. I sold my hulk and bought the new LV due to less green and prefer the newer dimensions

The CHNR is warm, less in your face which can be dressed up and down. I love the look of rose gold when the sun hits it right but I am not a fan of watch that is fully rose gold so the SS makes it for me. Of the two, it is the only one still in my collection.

So my opinion is the CHNR.